Depending on what you are trading (i.e. if it's not European Equities)... then IQ Feed is a good option. Much better value that eSignal... better service, rock solid live data.
--- In [email protected], "klebaric" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > The ones I have read about on the user's knowledge base which might > work are eSignal, JustData and csiData. I would like to get a sense > of which of these is likely to work best (for the items listed above) > in practice, based on people's experience. Would you have any > feedback on this question, perhaps based on your experience or what > you have heard from others? > > Thanks > > --- In [email protected], "Mike" <sfclimbers@> wrote: > > > > This will not answer all of your questions. But, have a look at > some > > of the information posted in the User's Knowledge Base: > > > > http://www.amibroker.org/userkb/ > > > > Particularly the sections dedicated to "System Automation" > and "Real > > Time Auto Trading". > > > > Mike > > > > --- In [email protected], "klebaric" <kl@> wrote: > > > > > > Hi, I am a beginning trader working on setting up a trading > platform > > > and data feed that I can use for doing some initial paper-trading > > > tests. I would like to select a platform and data feed which can > > > transition relatively smoothly to actual real-world use in auto- > > > trading. It would be great to get the forum's > feedback/suggestions > > re > > > which brokerage and data feeds are recommended > > > > > > I have 2 questions: > > > > > > 1) Which trading platform (i.e. brokerage) do you recommend for > the > > > above? Some background: I have tried the Interactive Brokers > (IB) > > > demo version of TWS, but had some problems in terms of getting it > to > > > show trades w/AmiBroker (I used an auto-trading AFL file in > > > AmiBroker, which correctly generates trades, but TWS seems not to > > > see/process them). I also had difficulties w/Backfill (it > wouldn't > > > backfill some symbols at all I was trying this after-hours). > > > Ideally, I would like to get something working on a demo/trial > basis > > > before going through the process of setting up and funding an > > > account, since, if the brokerage platform doesn't end up > integrating > > > well with AmiBroker, it would be time consuming and a hassle to > > close > > > the account and start up the same process w/another brokerage. > > > Alternately, if your experience is that a particular broker is > the > > > way to go and will work once one sets up an actual account > (rather > > > than using the demo version), please let me know? > > > > > > 2) Since the IB data feed seems to only backfill (i.e. provide > > > historical data) for 180 days, is there another data source that > you > > > can recommend for getting longer periods of historical data, from > a > > > wider range of markets, etc? In other words, do you have any > > > suggestions regarding which data feed will: > > > a. be the most straightforward/bug-free to integrate w/AmiBroker > and > > > IB > > > b. provide quality (cleaned-up) data > > > c. provide a wide range of markets (including lots of foreign > > > markets) and asset types (e.g. stocks, futures, ETFs, etc) > > > d. provide a long history (i.e. can go back a # of decades)? > > > I am willing to sign up with a data feed service a trial basis, > to > > > make sure it works. > > > > > > Thanks > > > > > >
