Hi Steve -- I think this question goes to Tomasz, rather than to me.
Thanks, Howard On Mon, Feb 2, 2009 at 9:56 AM, Steve Dugas <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi Howard, thanks for the nice post. I have been doing things like this > with > Equity() for several years now, but I see one major problem ( bug? ) when > doing it and I wonder if you might be able to comment or perhaps confirm > the > problem? > > It seems that, when we generate an equity line based on EOD trading it will > > calculate our equity based on the Close price, and when we generate the > equity line based on NDO trading it calculates our equity based on the Open > > price. This is fine, except that ( only ) when trading NDO, the last value > of the Equity array is apparently *not* calculated on the Open price like > all the other bars, and so when today's data is downloaded, and the last > bar > becomes the next-to-last bar, the equity value for that bar will *change*. > So if you are using the last value of Equity() as a condition for doing > something, say for example generating your signals, you run into a *very > real* problem of signals disappearing the next day, or signals coming a day > > late. As a practical matter, it seems that when trading NDO, the equity > line > really can't be used for anything other than just looking at it because it > is not *reliable*. Would you agree that this is the case? I have mentioned > this to TJ several times in the past but I don't think anything was ever > done to correct it, I guess I will take this opportunity to bring it up it > one more time and perhaps if you agree we could try to muster up some > support for getting it fixed. What do you think? My apologies to TJ if > there is something that I am not understanding correctly... > > Steve > > > ----- Original Message ----- > From: "Howard Bandy" <[email protected] <howardbandy%40gmail.com>> > To: <[email protected] <amibroker%40yahoogroups.com>> > Sent: Sunday, February 01, 2009 1:05 PM > Subject: [amibroker] Using the Equity Curve to control trading logic > > > Greetings all -- > > > > I have received a couple of inquiries about using the equity curve to > > control the logic of a trading system. Pasted into this posting is a > > trading system that includes two examples. There are a lot of other > > ways the equity curve can be used. > > > > Thanks, > > Howard > > > > > > // EquityCurveLogicSwitcher.afl > > // > > // Howard Bandy > > // February 2009 > > // > > // In response to an inquiry from the forums -- > > // > > // This is an example of using the daily equity > > // to control the logic of a trading system. > > // > > // Code two trading systems -- System 1 and System 2 > > // For this example, they are the reverse of each other. > > // > > // Compute a moving average of daily equity of System 1. > > // Refer to either today's value, or yesterday's, > > // depending on when you want to measure and when you > > // want to act and are able to act. > > // When the moving average of the equity curve of System 1 is > > // higher than it was the previous day, trade System 1. > > // When the moving average is lower, trade System 2. > > // > > // An alternative is to use only System 1. > > // Take signals in the original direction > > // when the equity curve is rising, > > // take signals in the opposite > > // direction when the equity curve is falling. > > // > > // ========================================================== > > // Disclaimer > > // > > // This is only an EXAMPLE, it is NOT A FINISHED TRADING SYSTEM. > > // There are a lot of subtleties to consider when coding > > // and potentially trading this. > > // > > // For example: > > // When do you enter and exit trades > > // When do you calcaulate the original equity curve > > // When do you measure the slope of the original equity curve > > // Making certain that a signal to go Short causes a Long position to > exit > > // And so forth > > // > > // > > // I have probably forgotten to do something important, > > // and this code is probably incorrect in exactly the way that > > // will cause you problems. > > // ========================================================== > > // > > // System 1 is a moving average crossover -- replace this > > // with whatever you want to use. > > > > // Code the two trading systems. > > > > MA1Len = Optimize("MA1Len",4,1,25,1); > > MA2Len = Optimize("MA2Len",5,1,25,1); > > > > MA1 = MA(C,MA1Len); > > MA2 = MA(C,MA2Len); > > > > System1Buy = Cross(MA1,MA2); > > System1Sell = Cross(MA2,MA1); > > > > System2Buy = Cross(MA2,MA1); > > System2Sell = Cross(MA1,MA2); > > > > // Compute the equity curve resulting from trading System 1. > > > > Buy = System1Buy; > > Sell = System1Sell; > > > > eSystem1 = Equity(); > > > > EquitySmoothLen = 252; > > SmoothedEquity = EMA(eSystem1,EquitySmoothLen); > > SmoothedEquityRising = SmoothedEquity > Ref(SmoothedEquity,-1); > > > > // The two options -- > > // TRUE == trade two systems > > // FALSE == trade System 1 in the opposite direction > > > > LogicOption = False; > > > > if (LogicOption) > > { > > // Use the slope of the equity curve of System 1 to > > // decide whether to trade System 1 or System 2. > > > > Buy = IIf(SmoothedEquityRising,System1Buy,System2Buy); > > Sell = IIf(SmoothedEquityRising,System1Sell,System2Sell); > > } > > else > > { > > // Use the slope of the equity curve of System 1 to > > // decide whether or Buy or Short when the System1Buy signal appears > > > > Buy = IIf(SmoothedEquityRising,System1Buy,0); > > Sell = IIf(SmoothedEquityRising,System1Sell,0); > > Short = IIf(NOT(SmoothedEquityRising),System1Buy,0); > > Cover = IIf(NOT(SmoothedEquityRising),System1Sell,0); > > Sell = Sell OR Short; > > Cover = Cover OR Buy; > > } > > > > e = Equity(); > > > > // Plot > > > > Plot(C,"C",colorBlack,styleCandle); > > Plot(MA1,"MA1",colorRed,styleLine); > > Plot(MA2,"MA2",colorBlue,styleLine); > > > > > Plot(SmoothedEquity,"SmoothedEquity",colorRed,styleLine|styleLeftAxisScale); > > Plot(eSystem1,"eSystem1",colorBlue,styleLine|styleLeftAxisScale); > > Plot(e,"eUsingSwitch",colorGreen,styleLine|styleLeftAxisScale); > > > > // The End > > // ---------------------------------------------- > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > > > **** IMPORTANT **** > > This group is for the discussion between users only. > > This is *NOT* technical support channel. > > > > ********************* > > TO GET TECHNICAL SUPPORT from AmiBroker please send an e-mail directly to > > SUPPORT {at} amibroker.com > > ********************* > > > > For NEW RELEASE ANNOUNCEMENTS and other news always check DEVLOG: > > http://www.amibroker.com/devlog/ > > > > For other support material please check also: > > http://www.amibroker.com/support.html > > > > ********************************* > > Yahoo! Groups Links > > > > > > > > > > >
