> I see no reason why not

Speed. 

Speed is the reason. Implementing what you wrote would mean resizing ALL 
variables already defined /assigned value to at the time of SetForeign
call instead of just 6 (OHLCVI) and this is very costly (memory re-allocation 
and possible fragmentation) in computing terms. Also since
those values are already calculated they would be padded with NULLS. So what 
would be gained from such operation ? Nothing. Just more memory consumption,
slower execution time and some more Nulls at the beginning of all arrays 
previously calculated.

Best regards,
Tomasz Janeczko
amibroker.com
  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Ton Sieverding 
  To: [email protected] 
  Sent: Wednesday, March 25, 2009 9:47 AM
  Subject: Re: Re[2]: [amibroker] SETFOREIGN does not give me the correct 
answer ...


  Tomasz/Herman thanks for the answer. The fact that SetForeign and Foreign 
should be in sync with the underlying array does not mean to me that these 
foreign arrays cannot be loaded for the full 100%. I really don't see why you 
could not have the following arrays in AB :

  Original Array                                   
|------------------------------------SSSSSSSSSS----|
  Foreign A                
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
  Foreign B                                                            
|----------------------------------------------|

  Where S is the Screen. Both Foreign A and Foreign B can be in sync with the 
Original array. I see no reason why not. But that's not how it's programmed in 
AB of course. When I am trying to get the first Close in Foreign A with 
Close[0] the result is Empty. Because Foreign A only starts where the original 
array starts. If for what ever reason I want the beginning values of Foreign A, 
it's impossible to get these values ... Other than first loading an Original 
Array that's longer than both Foreign A or B. This is what I am doing now. But 
that's not how I would like it to be. I thought I did something wrong. But it 
seems that's not the case ...

  Regards, Ton.


    ----- Original Message ----- 
    From: Tomasz Janeczko 
    To: [email protected] 
    Sent: Wednesday, March 25, 2009 1:06 AM
    Subject: Re: Re[2]: [amibroker] SETFOREIGN does not give me the correct 
answer ...



    Precisely. SetForeign and Foreign is intended to bring "other" symbol data 
in timestamp synchronized manner and it work
    is actuall described in the guide:
    http://www.amibroker.com/f?foreign

    Best regards,
    Tomasz Janeczko
    amibroker.com
      ----- Original Message ----- 
      From: Herman 
      To: Ton Sieverding 
      Sent: Tuesday, March 24, 2009 9:51 PM
      Subject: Re[2]: [amibroker] SETFOREIGN does not give me the correct 
answer ...


      afaik, Since Foreign is intended to plot on the current ticker's chart 
its elements are padded to conform to the current chart. If you want the 
foreign ticker to set the number of bars displayed you should make that one the 
current ticker and call the other tickers with foreign.




      It make sense that the current ticker does not change (is the reference) 
when you display foreign tickers, if it did the underlying symbol would be 
changing its number of bars all the time, i.e. sometimes it would be padded, at 
other times bars would be removed.




      herman







      Tuesday, March 24, 2009, 2:45:32 PM, you wrote:




            >
           Yep. That's what I did also. There is always another way to Rome. 
But that's not how I want it to work. SetForeign has the Symbol characteristics 
and therefore knows the number of elements and therefore should be able to 
resize the array ... Same for Foreign ... I am missing something ...



            Regards, Ton.



            ----- Original Message ----- 

            From: Steve Dugas 

            To: [email protected] 

            Sent: Tuesday, March 24, 2009 6:49 PM

            Subject: Re: [amibroker] SETFOREIGN does not give me the correct 
answer ...




            Hi - I don't believe SetForeign resizes the arrays, I think it just 

            overwrites the contents. I ran into that in the past, I think what 
I did 

            was to set the current ticker to an index or something with a very 
long 

            history and then search for the first non-null value. Might want to 
do a 

            quick plot of the foreign values though just to be sure...




            Steve




            ----- Original Message ----- 

            From: "amsiev" <[email protected]>

            To: <[email protected]>

            Sent: Tuesday, March 24, 2009 12:08 PM

            Subject: [amibroker] SETFOREIGN does not give me the correct answer 
...




            > Let's take 3 ETF's : AAXJ,BWV and EWN. I want to get the start 
date, first 

            > close etc. of each time series by using SetForeign. What's wrong 
with the 

            > following code ? It looks as if AB is using the selected symbol 
and not 

            > the symbol from the SETFOREIGN ... Must be something very simple 
but ...

            >

            > SetBarsRequired(sbrAll,sbrAll);

            >

            > SetForeign("AAXJ");

            > printf("Symbol "+Name()+"\n");

            > printf("First Close "+WriteVal(Close[0])+"\n");

            > printf("Last Close "+WriteVal(Close[BarCount-1])+"\n");

            > printf("Total Bars "+WriteVal(BarCount-1)+"\n");

            > printf("Start Date "+WriteVal( BeginValue( DateTime() ), 

            > formatDateTime )+"\n");

            >

            > SetForeign("BWV");

            > printf("Symbol "+Name()+"\n");

            > printf("First Close "+WriteVal(Close[0])+"\n");

            > printf("Last Close "+WriteVal(Close[BarCount-1])+"\n");

            > printf("Total Bars "+WriteVal(BarCount-1)+"\n");

            > printf("Start Date "+WriteVal( BeginValue( DateTime() ), 

            > formatDateTime )+"\n");

            >

            > SetForeign("EWN");

            > printf("Symbol "+Name()+"\n");

            > printf("First Close "+WriteVal(Close[0])+"\n");

            > printf("Last Close "+WriteVal(Close[BarCount-1])+"\n");

            > printf("Total Bars "+WriteVal(BarCount-1)+"\n");

            > printf("Start Date "+WriteVal( BeginValue( DateTime() ), 

            > formatDateTime )+"\n");

            >

            > Regards, Ton.

            >

            >

            >

            > ------------------------------------

            >

            > **** IMPORTANT PLEASE READ ****

            > This group is for the discussion between users only.

            > This is *NOT* technical support channel.

            >

            > TO GET TECHNICAL SUPPORT send an e-mail directly to

            > SUPPORT {at} amibroker.com

            >

            > TO SUBMIT SUGGESTIONS please use FEEDBACK CENTER at

            > http://www.amibroker.com/feedback/

            > (submissions sent via other channels won't be considered)

            >

            > For NEW RELEASE ANNOUNCEMENTS and other news always check DEVLOG:

            > http://www.amibroker.com/devlog/

            >

            > Yahoo! Groups Links

            >

            >

            >

            > 













           





    

Reply via email to