Hi SIG Members,


Please find below the legal impact assessment prepared as part of the SIG 
Guidelines Review.

The assessment identifies a number of observations and drafting considerations 
in relation to the current draft guidelines.

It is being shared with SIG members for information and review.
A plain text version of this assessment has also been published to the Working 
Groups page on the APNIC website 
<https://www.apnic.net/community/participate/sigs/wgs/>



--

Dave Phelan

Policy Manager and Senior Network Analyst

APNIC



----------



1. APNIC’s Understanding of the Proposal



APNIC understands the scope of the SIG Guidelines Working Group (WG) is a 
holistic review of the current APNIC-128-v004 SIG guidelines document. On 13 
July 2026 the WG agreed to take a principals-first approach to the review and 
shared its draft recommendations to the SIG mailing lists. The SIG Guidelines 
draft based on these principals was published to the mailing lists on 7 August 
2026.



2. Legal Impact of the Proposal



Section 2.4

CONFERENCE ATTENDANCE



The wording of section 2.4 ('SIG Chairs and Co-Chairs are expected to attend at 
least one of the two APNIC Conferences held each year.’) and section 3.6 ('If a 
SIG Chair or Co-Chair does not attend one in every two APNIC Conferences ... 
the APNIC EC will have discretion to remove the Chair or Co-Chair from their 
role’) would benefit from consistent language to avoid any misinterpretation as 
to how the criteria is to apply (i.e. 2.4 refers to conferences within a 
specific year, whereas 3.6 refers to two consecutive conferences).



Section 3



CO-CHAIR ELECTION TIMING



Section 3 makes reference to an initial Co-Chair term being one-year to enable 
the staggering of the Chair and Co-Chair elections. The document is silent on 
whether a second Co-Chair is to be elected at the same meeting as the other 
Co-Chair. We understand this to mean that the second Co-Chair will be elected 
commencing from the first meeting after it is determined that a second Co-Chair 
is required, i.e. it will be determined by the party calling for a second 
Co-Chair (either the Chair or the SIG). If this is not the intention, 
additional drafting may be required to confirm this.



COOLING-OFF PERIOD



We interpret the cooling-off period “of at least one year” following two 
consecutive terms of a Chair or Co-Chair to be the period between one AMM and 
the next AMM, or one AGM and the next AGM, rather than requiring a strict 
calendar year. As the timing of AGMs and AMMs is variable there may be 
instances where the time between one AMM and the next AMM is less than one year 
which, on a strict interpretation, would mean that the cooling-off period would 
still apply and therefore re-election would not be possible in that year. On a 
stricter interpretation, section 3 requires that such a person is only eligible 
to “run for election again” after the “cooling-off period of at least one year” 
has passed. As the criteria applies to “run[ning] for election” and as 
nominations close in advance of the relevant conference, thereby shortening the 
time further, the cooling-off period would quite likely have the practical 
effect of operating as a two-year period.



Section 3.7



ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR ACTING CHAIRS



The eligibility criteria under section 3.4.1 is not entirely applicable to the 
appointment of Acting Chairs as contemplated by section 3.7.

Section 3.4.1 expects that nominees must attend and be eligible to vote at the 
‘current conference’, however there may not be a ‘current conference’ (i.e. one 
with registration open) at the time of the Acting Chair appointment, as well as 
other “nominee” specific provisions.



Our interpretation is that the attendance requirement would not apply where the 
Acting Chair appointment occurs outside of a period during which conference 
registrations are open. We have also interpreted that the following “nominee” 
specific provisions in section 3.4.1 will apply to an Acting Chair: that they 
must reside within the Asia Pacific service region; must not be staff members 
of an RIR or ICANN; and must not hold another elected position (unless they 
resigned from that position as part of accepting the Acting Chair role). In 
general, this may benefit from additional drafting clarity, particularly if the 
above interpretation does not align with the intention.



3. Implementation



If this proposal was to reach consensus, changes would be required to APNIC-128.

Implementation time frame would be subject to the APNIC Document editorial 
policy (APNIC-112)


_______________________________________________
APNIC-talk - https://mailman.apnic.net/[email protected]/
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to