Dear colleagues,
This is a short summary of the Joint SIGs session on the SIG GuidelinesReview,
held at APNIC 62 in Mumbai on 9 September 2026.
No consensus call was held on the draft SIG Guidelines (v005), in wholeor in
part.
WHAT WAS PROPOSED
The v005 draft, published on 7 August, groups its changes under fiveareas: term
limits (four terms across all SIGs, with a cooling-off periodadded after
community comment); a SIG lifecycle with dissolutionsafeguards; the SIG charter
elevated to Terms of Reference; Chair andCo-Chair duties and elections; and the
unchanged procedure for amendingthe Guidelines.
WHAT THE COMMUNITY RAISED
Eight themes came out of the mailing lists and the session:
1. Whether the APNIC EC should be able to remove an elected Chair or Co-Chair
(section 3.6). The clause dates from 2016 and the draft adds due process. It
will have a standalone consensus call.
2. "APNIC Conference" needs formal definitions, since ticketing differs
between standalone and APRICOT-co-located events.
3. Nominees must attend in person while sitting Chairs may attend remotely.
Visa and travel costs were raised as barriers.
4. The nomination window stays at four weeks. Member-organization voting was
agreed at APNIC 55 in 2023. "SIG member" is undefined.
5. Whether the draft goes beyond the Working Group's 9 June agreement. The
Working Group has recorded which parts carry its unanimous agreement.
6. Who decides consensus. The Working Group is advisory only; the SIG Chairs
decided not to hold a consensus call.
7. Whether the EC may establish a Working Group, and how consensus at a
"Joint SIGs Forum" is assessed.
8. The Secretariat's impact assessment raised four drafting points, not yet
formally answered.
WORKING GROUP STATUS
Under its original Terms of Reference, the Working Group was to concludeat
APNIC 62 unless an extension was agreed as an outcome of the session.The SIG
Chairs discussed this off-mic, but no formal decision was madein Mumbai. They
have since agreed that the review should continue and,to broaden community
participation, will add members to the WorkingGroup.
NEXT STEPS
- An Expression of Interest will be sent to the mailing lists shortly,
inviting community members to join the Working Group.- The Working Group's
Terms of Reference will be updated with a new timeline and outputs, to be
published once confirmed.- The Working Group will work through the feedback
received and bring proposed text changes back to the community.
Feedback remains welcome on the SIG mailing lists or directly to theWorking
Group.
Sources:- Draft v005:
https://ftp.apnic.net/apnic/drafts/apnic-128-v005-draft.txt- Diff:
https://ftp.apnic.net/apnic/drafts/apnic-128-v005-draft.diff.html- Impact
assessment: https://ftp.apnic.net/apnic/drafts/apnic-128-v005-draft-IA.txt-
Session recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gTwj7-XFD8Y
Regards,
Terry SweetserJoint SIGs Chair(on behalf of the SIG Chairs)
_______________________________________________
APNIC-talk - https://mailman.apnic.net/[email protected]/
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]