On Sun, Mar 1, 2015 at 3:47 PM, Mel Beckman <[email protected]> wrote:
Dave,
I appreciate all your work on buffer bloat. It looks like you have done quite a
lot of selfless contribution. However, I don't think you're effectively
communicating with the people who can change things.
After I read what you said, here is what I would have heard as a service
provider:
"I am the smartest person in the room.
I am pretty close to being the smartest person in the room. That said,
people like van jacobson, eric dumazet, tom herbert, jim gettys, eric
raymond, vint cerf, dave reed, fred baker, and many, many others,
smarter than me, have also been banging this drum, politely, and
rationally, to not much effect, for 4+ years now.
google for any of those names and the word "bufferbloat".
You better listen to me, because if you don't there will be trouble. But you
probably won't because you're too stupid. Your customers suffer because you are
idiots. Listen to me! This issue is too important for me to be polite, or even
coherent. If you can't figure out what I'm saying, do some research and figure it
out! Plus, apologize to me! I demand it!"
Oh, banning my ip for *3 links to sane benchmarks and fixes*,
realllllly pushed me over the edge.
Bees, honey, vinegar, etc.
I have been polite, constructive, and helpful, for four+ years. I have
worked both in the background and foreground with many companies, to
start hopefully, getting bufferbloat fixed across the entire edge of
the internet. It hasn't worked fast enough for my liking, and the last
batch of new products that claimed to fix it, didn't, and the market
is now rife with genuine lies as to whether they did or not.
So, this morning, I tried this. Sorry for the noise on these lists.
Honestly! I totally agree with your assessment of my tone, btw! but I
would rather like the cable industry in particular, to come clean,
with schedules for deployable fixes.
I am off to go fix wifi next, and I do hope that 2+ billion people in
the world - if not the isps, maybe - would like wifi to get better
also, and indeed, I spent the weekend constructively starting to
implement some of the fixes I outlined at the last 802.11 meeting I
attended. That part, on fixing wifi bufferbloat - a much harder
problem than edge bufferbloat - , is a lot of fun! For some info on
what we plan to do there, see:
http://snapon.lab.bufferbloat.net/~d/ieee802.11-sept-17-2014/11-14-1265-00-0wng-More-on-Bufferbloat.pdf
So I took a break from that, reared back, and got some stuff off my chest.
