On Fri, 22 Nov 2002 01:21:32 -0700, G J Feig wrote:

> Oh, yes it does.  You make that statement without knowing the
> volume I got before blocking and the volume I now get, plus, I can
> easily go check to see "how many Mbytes has been blocked today"...<g>

>> As you can see.
>> Blocking eMails from particular ISPs or entire domains is not the answer.

> Maybe in your case, just ONE case, here, this has been deleterious.
> ....and...maybe it IS an imposition by your ISP...  Where it is my ISP
> setting it up for ME to do the "whole domain blocking" then it is
> NOT deleterious, and not an imposition.

People should be able to have things the way they want them. If you
want domains blocked, then block away.

I don't want any domains blocked by my ISP. I have good friends and
relatives with hotmail, yahoo, msn, aol accounts. Maybe I want to
get messages from Russia or India or China or who knows where.
That's the way I want it.

But if spam gets your knickers in a twist, then blocking the most
popular free account domains might indeed limit the amount of spam
you get. If that's where it's coming from, I don't know. Sounds
reasonable.

But, holy smokes, are you guys really getting megabytes of spam
daily? I'd like to hear a firm figure from someone who knows
for sure--not just a wild guess.

Maybe if I got that much I'd want to do something. But right
now, I don't care. My ISP offers "spam filtering" but I declined
to have it turned on because they wouldn't tell me the criteria
used to filter. Not even in a vague, non-specific way. I just
didn't like that at all. My viewpoint was not appreciated by the
ISP. They couldn't believe I didn't want it.


What happens to an email arriving from a blocked domain? Is it
bounced back with an explanation? Would the legitimate user know
that his email had been blocked? And why? That's why I declined
the "spam filtering" offer. It just seemed like useless rigamarol
to me that might make it harder to communicate with people that I
want to hear from.

Quite frankly I have a hard time understanding why spam gets such
a reaction from some people. Hardly more than a very low level
nusicance to me, if that.


Sam Ewalt
Croswell, Michigan, USA
-- Arachne V1.70;rev.3, NON-COMMERCIAL copy, http://arachne.cz/

Reply via email to