James Carlson wrote: >> I also see a few ARC members who I know are active in OpenSolaris reviews >> that are missing, so I nominate as new Core Contributors of the ARC >> community: >> John Fischer >> Garrett D'Amore >> Darren Moffat > > +1 to Fisher as a current LSARC member, and +1 to Darren as a current > PSARC member. > > I have a problem with nominating someone who is not a full ARC member > as a Core Contributor, and despite his contributions, Garrett is not.
He is not? He is listed as a full member on http://sac.eng/PSARC/ (as was Bill - I relied on that list, and forgot it doesn't show which members are "on sabbatical".) > We do have an ARC membership process ... shouldn't that existing > process *be* the Core Contributor determining process? > > In other words, should we even be doing this vote? At the moment, I don't think the Constitution allows any options other than a vote of the current Core Contributors for naming new ones, and requires that groups maintain their Core Contributors or be dissolved. The new Constitution [1], should the Core Contributors vote to accept it, will offer groups the freedom of defining their own membership process, as well as splitting that from the OGB election voting pool. [1] Currrent draft at: http://wiki.genunix.org/wiki/index.php/OGB_2008/010_OpenSolaris_Constitution_2009 -- -Alan Coopersmith- alan.coopersmith at sun.com Sun Microsystems, Inc. - X Window System Engineering
