Hi Joe,

I agree with you about the table topic meetings, and the ability to discuss
things without a policy proposal involved.

I think your second paragraph borders on ad hominem, but you are correct
that may of the contributors have other interests, but those should be
ignored in favor of the argument stated.

And I agree with the sentiment that ARIN is not a profit-seeking entity. 
I disagree however, that ARIN is just a vehicle for members to express
competing arguments outside the scaffolding of the original intent expressed
in RFC2050.

And I think the community recognized the effects on conservation of an IPv4
market. I think it was basically forced by economic arguments to essentially
abandon the policies in place for three decades, which involved voluntary
return and re-allocation to those in need. In fact I would say the community
recognized the primacy of the market as opposed the  ancient regime, which
exacerbated exhaust. And which you still seem to extoll:

" Not all members are driven by profit motive. Some members see
that accidents of history should not magically deliver a
largess. Others understand the agreements they made to get
allocations guide that when resources are not being used per
their allocation intent, they should return to the allocating
authority."

And please tell me when the RIRs became the equalizers between poor and
rich. I mean, I see them plainly in policy, such as excluding from the
waitlist those with more than a /20. I don't see them in the founding
documents, though. If the design of the RIRs involved equalizing the rich
and the poor, I missed that. 

I believe that most of the donations to the waiting list pool are from
reclamations, not voluntary donations. Maybe staff can be more informative
regarding recovered addresses, something you will note that I have argued
for here and elsewhere.

I am in agreement with you that there is no real problem with the waiting
list. I have identified what I think are general problems introducing "free"
into a priced pool. I think the waiting list works, but then again, I didn't
choose the table topic.

And I agree with you that transparency would be the best approach. For
example, why are there 12,000 /24s coming in?  That is an odd amount of
non-contiguous address space.

Regards,

Mike
















-----Original Message-----
From: ARIN-PPML <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Joe Provo via
ARIN-PPML
Sent: Friday, October 30, 2026 10:45 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [arin-ppml] ARIN 58 Table Topic - If the Waitlist didn???t
exist, what would?

Hey all,

I always appreciate the meeting "table topics"; their intent is to spur
discussion and you never know which will be successful in that goal. As they
are not plenary discussion, they are not necessarily "problems" which need
to be fixed.  

There are definitely parties with commercial interests who view the
existence of waiting list as a problem. Folks whose businesses are tightly
coupled to this temporary market for integers (created to incent
organizations to return unused resources to the Internet
community) have a disincentive to see both: 
- IPv6-mostly/IPv6-only networks proliferate
- IPv4 allocation mobility outside of their markets


echarlie> If IPv4 is a cost center for us as an RIR, but also
echarlie> has relatively high value on the open market, why
echarlie> *shouldn't* we dispose of it in a way that increases
echarlie> that value while providing revenue?

ARIN is not a profit-seeking entity. As a member-based nonprofit
with a specific mission to support "the operation and growth of
the Internet", it is *ALL* cost. As such, there's no foundation
to this argument; our membership fees need to keep operations
going and that's it. ARIN should not be seeking additional
revenue.

mike@sum> I am opposed to it because generally, introducing
mike@sum> into a priced market a resource that is free will
mike@sum> tend to distort the market and invite corruption.

This is a flat inversion of history. The temporary market for
integers was created for two reasons: 
- incent holders of integers not used on the public Internet to
  make them available to others
- disincent unethical transactions (so-called "gray market" by
  apologists) concealing resource-holders from the public
  registry

Period. That's it. There is no primacy or supremacy of market-
driven distribution of integers. 


mike@sum> ARIN is not a charity; that would not be consonant
mike@sum> with its purpose.

There is no "charity" in fulfilling its nonprofit goal to support
the operation and growth of the Internet. Member-driven policies
have developed and refined the existence of the waiting list.
Even if the ARIN CEO has stated at multiple meetings that he
doesn't understand why folks return addresses to ARIN rather
than participate in the temporary marketplace, members do just
this.

Not all members are driven by profit motive. Some members see
that accidents of history should not magically deliver a
largess. Others understand the agreements they made to get
allocations guide that when resources are not being used per
their allocation intent, they should return to the allocating
authority.

mike@sum> RIRs are for uniqueness and conservation. Not for
mike@sum> equalizing little guys and big guys.

The history of this and *any* policies disagrees with your
assertion. ARIN exists to implement the will of the membership
in fulfillment of its mission.  Fairly often, policy discussions
have *expressly* called out ensuring that small/nonprofit 
operators or community networking members or other non-big-
pockets entities not be locked out of Internet resources. PPML,
Public Policy Meeting notes, and AC meeting minutes over the
decades document this. 

mike@sum> Nobody will charitably give away IPv4 blocks.

Again, the blocks coming into the waiting list that aren't
reclaims (and the CEO's frequent statements at meetings)
demonstrate this is not true. 


I'm in largely in agreement with Fernando, Mark Van Daele,
and Tyler Donia.  What's actually amiss in the waiting list?
Some additional transparency in the process it seems.

Cheers,

Joe

-- 
Posted from my personal account - see X-Disclaimer header.
Joe Provo / Gweep / Earthling 
_______________________________________________
ARIN-PPML
You are receiving this message because you are subscribed to
the ARIN Public Policy Mailing List ([email protected]).
Unsubscribe or manage your mailing list subscription at:
https://lists.arin.net/mailman/listinfo/arin-ppml
Please contact [email protected] if you experience any issues.

_______________________________________________
ARIN-PPML
You are receiving this message because you are subscribed to
the ARIN Public Policy Mailing List ([email protected]).
Unsubscribe or manage your mailing list subscription at:
https://lists.arin.net/mailman/listinfo/arin-ppml
Please contact [email protected] if you experience any issues.

Reply via email to