u r right karthik :) ....... 3 cheers to u ...lets hope we get another iruvar !!!!
--- In [email protected], "S, Karthik" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Hey Guys, > > Chill out...These arguments are completely unnecessary..I mean, Akash has to understand that arr_madrasi is a passionate ARR fan and arr_madrasi should understand that what Aakash is saying that it won't add any value if we belittle any other composer of yester year and ARR still has few furlongs to go before he is coveted BR which by Go's grace he will be one day.. > End of the fight..Enjoy Guru...Lets hope that this album turns out as one another Iruvar kind of a brilliant album which took on the masses and the classes slowly but now stands out as one of ARRs all time greats. > I obviously want Guru to become one of ARR's great if it really has that potential. > > Regards, > Karthik > > ________________________________ > > From: [email protected] on behalf of arr_madrasi > Sent: Wed 11/15/2006 12:44 PM > To: [email protected] > Subject: Re: [arr] GROSS INJUSTICE..BIAS against Rahman by cnn-ibn (req to moderator) > > > > i dont think it is far fetched at all that Rahman is a potential > bharat ratna awardee . When MS , Lata Mangeshkar , Satyajit Ray and > Bismillah Khan have been awarded , I am very sure that Rahman who > has contributed greatly to the field of arts is definitely in the > race . get ur facts b4 u speak mr Aakarsh. > Hes just 40 . probably one day when he wins an oscar , u might take > back whatever uve said . I am sure a lot of sane minded Indians agree > with whatever i have said . Rahman is no less an icon compared to > Lata ji or MS amma or Ray da or even Kahn sahib . I remember vividly > in one interview in which Naushaad sahb himself admitted that Rahman > is a living musical genius of our times . > Aakarsh , u have an entitlement to ur views , and please dont be > dogmatic about it , i respect ur viewpoint but it is grossly unfair > to say that i insulted Ilayaraja ! puh leez dude , i respect the man > and his music . All i said was that Rahman's reach and knowledge of > application of music surpasses that of Ilayaraja , which is a fact . > I am not the only one saying this . Only a jaundiced mind would deny > this . Raja was a musical genius , but RAhman is a musical god . > Period .End of argument ! > Chill out Aakarash and enjoy the music of Guru , i am sure u'll like > it more than a Nayagan or a Thalabathi :)DD > arr rocks > > --- In [email protected] <mailto:arrahmanfans% 40yahoogroups.com> , Kamal Aakarsh Vishnubhotla > <aakarsh_vk@> wrote: > > > > I dont want to argue about who is more eligible and who is not..But > dont you think that its too farfetched to expect that Rahman is a > potential Bharat Ratna awardee. Probably you have a flippant idea > about the worth of that award. Please check the recipients so far and > then weigh the eligibility. > > with due respects to Rahman & his talent, Rahman has a long way > to go to win teh coveted award. > > > > And i dont see the reason why people here try to degrade other > composers (and more importantly senior composers whom rahman himself > respects), in order to Glorify rahman. Everyone has their own > place...and everyone deserves their own due... > > > > Anyways, ur personal opinions might trigger controversy here. I > request the moderator to intervene and see that all the fans maintain > their mature admiration for Rahman instead of writing insulting > statements about the talent of other great composers. > > > > Regards > > Aakarsh. > > > > arr_madrasi <arr_madrasi@> wrote: > > Today morning , i was just checking out the morning news > on cnn-ibn . > > There was this poll for the greatest tamilian of all time . MS , > > Periyar , Abdul kalam , Rajni and Ilayaraja have been nominated . > No > > nomination for the only and real maestro :( . > > > > I dont know in what way Ilayaraja has contributed more than A R > > Rahman for India or even in promotion of Tamil music in India (note > > not TAmil NAdu) , I respect Ilayaraja , his music and his evergreen > > melodies . But no way can he edge out Rahman for the prize of all > > time best Tamil . This looks like a clearly biased list and its sad > > that a Padmashri awardee and a potential Bharat ratna awardee has > > been given the pass :( . > > > > I just wanna know what my fellow Tamils and non-Tamils in this > forum > > feel about this injustice . > > > > Mark my words , Rahman probably can be compared to Bharatiyar in > > terms of evoking patriotism and his role in promoting tamil > culture . > > In no way is he inferior , if at all superior(which is grossly > > obvious!!:)) then any regional music director that Tamil Nadu has > > ever seen !!! Tell me in the recording history, which recording > > artist insisted on having a Tamil Song as a condition for signing > the > > agreement , Rahman did so for a Tamil version of Vande Mataram with > > Sony music! Rahman is up there with the trinity of music , so what > if > > he composes film music , his knowledge in music both carnatic and > > folk , is unparalleled , his future works Inshallah will reflect > just > > that . Wait till u guys see the opening song in Sivaji . I heard in > > Tamil music history , no song has been composed with this intensity > > and folk application . Rahman , Tamil Nadu needs you and so does > > Tamil music .Come back if you are reading this , we are tired of > the > > jeyarajs and yuvans who just rehash ur old tunes and attempt 'hip- > > hop'....jeez what crap. > > > > Ur the real Raja and Isai gnani .....!!! All the best for Guru and > > Jodha bhai . I wish u overtake Naushaad with the music of > AkbarJodha > > and lets hope u win more hearts with these attempt than awards , > cos > > filmfare awards and national awards are for lesser mortals like our > > very own regional music directors who have so much head weight , ur > > much more than just a nomination material for these rigged awards . > I > > still cannot forgive Filmfare for giving Main hoon naa best music > > award over Swades inspite of u winning best BAckground music > > composer ! , Joke of the century.... :DDDD ! > > > > ARR rocks > > > > > > > > > > > > > > --------------------------------- > > Check out the all-new Yahoo! Mail beta - Fire up a more powerful > email and get things done faster. > > >
