I personal dont feel that ARR is composing music for competition. He is very dedicated musician who composes melodious tunes. ARR is still and will remain as the strongest music director of all time. As far as HJ is concerned he reuses his old tunes add some new tune and composes one song. HJ is very poor in versatality. I bet MDs like HJ couldnt have composed songs for masterpiece films like JA, Sivaji,Lagaan etc. Its only ARR who can compose songs for different genere. He is the Emperor of Music.
--- On Sat, 16/8/08, Prashanth Murali Nottath <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: From: Prashanth Murali Nottath <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [arr] Re:Harris Jeyaraj better than A.R.Rehman( my reply) To: [email protected] Date: Saturday, 16 August, 2008, 1:01 PM Hi, Fun thing here is that the guy is comparing Boss's Hindi albums with Tamil Composers! Tamil Music Industry requires a different set of enjoyment aspects (Sivaji, Sakkarakkatti) etc, while in Hindi the requirements are different. The maestro recognises that and is able to churn out hits in both ways. No wonder his tracks rule the roost in both languages, which is phenomenal. As to Ada, it is a wonderful, wonderful album. I thought it was a better album than JTYJN. Though JTYJN is THE MOST POPULAR ALBUM this year. Harris Jayaraj is a talented, but a bit one-dimensional in my opinion. However there are fresh voices coming up in Tamil Industry like Vasanth Saravanan (Subrahmanyapuram) etc. Instead of pitching all them straight up against the meastro, why don't we enjoy the value addition they provide to music? These are exciting times! Music is a sea, and any question of competition is just a joke. Regards, Prash. On 04/08/2008, Hakkeem <[EMAIL PROTECTED] com> wrote: Hi, Its true, ARR had deviated a loooot from common flocks( but he proved he can be the very old same ARR thru his scroes in ATM which still hits the charts of FM , tv's & as Dailertones) .Its true, & no doubt that all music lovers consider ARR as god ,but what I am stronly against is for the blind praise or upraisal for mediocre scores or albums like ADA,JTYN,Sakarakati etc.Well, HJ is not the only person who creates some catchy numbers, there are many like Yuvan, srikanth,Jousha, Himesh,Sajid etc etc( but many of thier songs are ' a true lift' from english and arabic albums).This is my personal comment with full respect to our Boss,above all there is no space here in this sub continent to rate with ARR . Kind regards, Hakkeem.A (I Support AR Rahman foundation and unicef ) --- On Mon, 8/4/08, Vithur <[EMAIL PROTECTED] com> wrote: From: Vithur <[EMAIL PROTECTED] com> Subject: [arr] Music: Harris Jeyaraj sounds better than A.R.Rehman To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com Date: Monday, August 4, 2008, 2:08 PM Music: Harris Jeyaraj sounds better than A.R.Rehman After the tamil hit of Minnale ,Harris Jeyajaj has established his own kind of music in the southern states of India. It looks simple,yet powerful soul music. Every film he worked ,he has given lot of melodies. One might say, he lacks variations, but he has understood the need of the film industry very well and giving music accordingly. He has followed the quality of A.R.Rehman but melody is different from the other. The lyrics is followable ,one can murmur it easily.Each of his venture is a musical success,but some numbers have repetitive patterns. He is yet to prove a success in Bollywood. Talking of Rehman ,he has deviated a lot from his early day musics. He is trying to follow the world music. His mix is good but many times it becomes very difficult to follow from common man's perspective. http://stock18. blogspot. com/2008/ 08/music- harris-jeyajaj- sounds-better- than.html P.S. THIS IS CERTAINLY NOT WRITTEN BY ME. EVEN IN MY DREAMS, WOULD I TELL SUCH A THING. PLS REPLY YOUR COMMENTS ON THAT BLOG. -- regards, Vithur ARR -- The Sweet Cube always -- Temet Nosce Add more friends to your messenger and enjoy! Go to http://in.messenger.yahoo.com/invite/
