Why Ghai should not??...It's my question.. what is wrong with u guys?...Tell me in detail what's wrong in 'western classical ' music..Why ARR should not compose tunes in western music?.. I challenge very few still listens 'Zubeida' which is complete 'Indian Classical'..grow up ppl..do not be such narrow minded..
Jiban Dass --- In [email protected], "Pravinder Sheoran" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Hi Farzad, > I was shocked and stunned when i read your message and your comment, > "are you the assistant of joginder tuteja" about me. > > Well man, first of all just to open your eyes, please read the > following message that I wrote when Jodhaa Akbar was released and find > out my relationship with joginder tuteja: > > "Teach IndiaFM a lesson, write to Editor" [Message no. 88483] > > Now, my following 3 messages will clarify your allegation that I wrote > same stuff when Guru was released: > > 1. GURU : After watching 4th time (For Rahman this time) [Message no. > 75211] > 2. Extension: GURU : After watching 4th time (For Rahman this time) > [Message no. 75220] > 3. (semi-arr) GURU : After watching 3rd time (only for Rajiv Menon) > [Message no. 75180]. > > How could you write, "Duplicate post..... Pravinder, same comment came > out when Guru came out...". Did you put any proof that i said so? > Did you even bother finding out anything about me before writing your > message? > > If I had known that I'll have to pay such a big price of writing that > I do not like the music of "Yuvvraj trailer", I would have never ever > written that mail. > > Pravinder. > > > > > --- In [email protected], "Farzad Khaleel" <farsad666@> > wrote: > > > > Duplicate post..... Pravinder, same comment came out when Guru came > out... > > > > All th awrd ppls were wrong, they gave away all the awards to > Guru.... and > > also indeed Outstanding achivemnt by an Indian by IIFA :P > > > > are you the assistant of joginder tuteja :P > > > > On Sun, Oct 5, 2008 at 4:56 AM, Pravinder Sheoran < > > pravindersheoran@> wrote: > > > > > Hi Chord and all, > > > I completely agree with chord. > > > After seeing the trailers, i have no doubts left that there is nothing > > > to hope out of this movie. > > > Also, i am sorry to say but the music in the trailer is not impressive > > > at all. > > > It looks like Ghai has intervened too much and have forced ARR to > > > commercialize his music. > > > ARR himself has also been into commercialization than he ever was. > > > First JTYJN (I still listen JA songs more than JTYJN) and now Yuvvraj. > > > Upcoming Gajni will also be more commercialized coz of Aamir factor. > > > So all we are left with is Private album of ARR and Dilli 6. > > > > > > My prediction about Yuvvraj could be wrong when music releases (I pray > > > god I'm wrong), but trailer of Yuvvraj sugests something else. > > > > > > Pravinder. > > > > > > --- In [email protected] <arrahmanfans% 40yahoogroups.com>, > > > "Chord" <purevibz@> wrote: > > > > > > > > I get it that he wanted to make a movie about music. But, why > > > > couldn't he have chosen Indian classical music? From photos and > > > > promos, the whole music scene looks Western. Why not make a film > with > > > > sitar, tabla, sarangi, tanpura, flute, santoor, instead of piano, > > > > violin, choirs? This is INDIA afterall. Oh well, director's freedom > > > > can't be challenged, but choice of music culture is what I question. > > > > > > > > I also feel that Ghai tries to be extra glossy and flashy in his > > > > films, with recent films testifying to more style and less > substance, > > > > hence BO failures. Hence, the western classical backdrop is more in > > > > line with his flashy, glossy film-making style. Having Indian > > > > classical music as a core musical backdrop would be too traditional > > > > and in his mind, boring. But, imagine the magic of Rahman's music if > > > > he composed for a film based on Indian classical music. Traditional > > > > Indian music is ARR's forte, not Western classical, even though he > > > > excels in that too. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > Farzad Khaleel > > Webmaster > > http://rahmaniac.co.nr > > >
