--- In [email protected], "Chord" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > As a Rahman fan, I take great offense!!! > > "Even the usually infallible AR Rahman sounds like he's channeling > Viju Shah's greatest hits, and while Ghai's always managed to create > enchanting soundtracks, this one is forgettable and staid". > > What the heck? Didn't Rediff give a 4 star rating for the music when > it came out? What happened now, the money didn't come through? This > remark is just outrageous and I think ARR fans should protest!!!! >
I don't think there is anything like a "rediff review". There are reviews on rediff. Reviews by different reviewers. If Raja Sen as a person/critic/audience member doesn't like something and publishes it as a part of his review, it really shouldn't be represented as a "comment by rediff". That is exactly why it does not make any sense to say that "rediff gave a 4 star rating for the music". It wasn't rediff. It was Sukanya Verma. Do you really want to say that if Sukanya Verma likes the music then Raja Sen doesn't have any right to not like it? Or is it just a plain case of "no one has the right to say something like that about ARR"? :) Please lighten up. Reviews are just opinions of people who are writing them. And they have their own tastes/opinions. We might not agree with them, but that is neither here nor there. If there was any objective "good" or "bad" about these things then every movie would've have either a perfect 100% or a 0% Rottentomatoes ratings. Rahul
