Good observation Jamshidji... True. Hindi Ghajini is class, while Tamil Ghajini was somewhat mass...
On Tue, Dec 30, 2008 at 10:14 AM, jamshid TC <[email protected]> wrote: > I think the issue is predictability. if you have watched tamil( that > too 2-3 times) beforehand. > movie is somuch predictable(as the movie is a scence by scene remake ( > almost).) and kills some fun. > > I was sure this will happen with Hindi ghajini . > > I had got Tamil Ghajini DVD one month back as my wife had not seen the > movie . But i wanted to do this experiment with her. i insisted her to watch > HIndi ghajini first and agreed to watch tamil ghajini second . (we watched > kakka kakka once again that day instead ). > > Now she watched Hindi first on thursday (and liked it very much) and we > watched tamil yesterday . and she says she likes the hindi version far far > better than tamil. > > Has anybody here done this "Ulta" way ? it would be interesting to know. > > I like lots of HJ compositions , but hindi ghajini music has got more > repete value than tamil .hindi ghajini is HINDI. if they did the same tamil > songs in hindi , i am sure it would have met the same fate of minnale.ARR > had the right audience in his mind while making the hindi ghajini i would > say.and thats why he is international now!! and most of the good regional > music directors are still regional. > > Just a share of my experince. > > -Jamshid > > --- On *Mon, 12/29/08, Vithur <[email protected]>* wrote: > > From: Vithur <[email protected]> > Subject: Re: [arr] Boss should not have done Ghajini > To: [email protected] > Date: Monday, December 29, 2008, 8:11 AM > > This may be because of people who get influenced by the Tamil Movie and > the Music... People who would not have seen the Tamil Version will surely > love the Hindi version much better > > I saw the Tamil version thrice, and as Gomzy had said,,, Surya's acting was > little better than Aamir's... in some scenes, but certainly the Hindi ending > and the climax is much better > > On Mon, Dec 29, 2008 at 9:05 PM, kishore kumar <kichu_c...@yahoo. > com<[email protected]> > > wrote: > >> >> Dont get angry with the subject line. I thought of writing this only >> because of the comments made by some people, It is painful . Ghajini >> Hindi version is a real classic compared to Tamil version. Although Tamil >> version has the mass appeal but still it is nowhere near Hindi Version. But >> people say that Tamil Version had good songs and Hindi is not impressive. We >> can say that this is not their cup of tea, but these comments hurts. Had >> these songs been in any other movie it would have been called class. I had a >> thought for sometime that Boss should not have done Ghajini. But still our >> Boss Rocks!!!! No other MD can even think of a song like Behka and Kaise >> Mujhe. When someone give bad comments I ask them to listen to Kaise Mujhe >> song.. >> >> > > > -- > regards, > Vithur > > > > > > -- regards, Vithur
