Saying any MD would have won oscar in sdm is like saying anybody who goes to Harward is great. but even Harward also has expection. Also what those who say anybody could have done it don't even have the slightest thought that why were those anybody not approached by danny? why didn't danny follow those anybody than AR? going to harward can make you great but t also requires enough to be qualified to be there. Same is with AR he got SDM just bcs of his previous works which proved exceptional. Why didanybody fail to make the mark of roja, Bombay ..... Where are those anybody? Why do they always follow AR? Remeber AR is a reason for change. Talking about many were better than SDM , yes they might be, but they can't be added to SDM and get qualified in gg or oscar bcs it needs original. Sdm is a vehicle to carry AR to the world over. We know all his work so have lot to compare. But oscar can't reject or accept SdM music looking at his prev work. Why can't somebody think. Yes all his prev work deserves oscar but was there the vehicle. How many movies he worked really qualify to the race? Excpt lagaan. Unfortunately many movies he scored great even failed to impress the audience.
There's AB who say oscar is not all, but who said it's all over either after oscar? It's an award and it's of great happiness for any countrymen being honoured. The current ten would have never knew about satyajit ray had it not been an oscar honoured. How many chapters do we have to remember that legend --- In [email protected], mb4zap® <moinboss4...@...> wrote: > > yah! i dnt agree at all for obvious reasons! most of these Indian MDs are bz getting INSPIRATION and if possible straight copy/paste from International artistes and global hits! Original compositions are very rare and impossible to many... let not talk about international recognision and... awards are even far cry!! > > it's completely insane to say most of Indian MDs are capable of.... and please don't underestimate ARR's talent and focus more on other factors... ARR is utmost generous person and he always tends to shy away from taking credits... we should be smart enough to understand the fact that apart from all factor it's actually him and his creations tht fetched him all tht he has and makes him wat he is today. > > --- On Mon, 1/26/09, Jahanzeb Farooq <jahanzebti...@...> wrote: > From: Jahanzeb Farooq <jahanzebti...@...> > Subject: [arr] Re: Suchi's comments on Radio One > To: [email protected] > Date: Monday, January 26, 2009, 6:03 AM > > > > > > > > > > > > so you mean even if Himesh, Anu, Pritam etc etc gave music to SDM they > > would have also ended winning an Oscar for music?? > > it would be the last thing in my life to agree. i strongly believe no > > one could have come with such an awesome score in SDM as ARR. no one. > > never. > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, "n_kumaar" <n_kumaar@ .> wrote: > > > > > > i agree with Murali. getting an award is likea big praise to an > > > artist. Certain artist get it and certain dont. Even for AR, i > > > personally believed his work in tamil and hindi films were far > > better > > > then Slumdog but he got he recognition due the right stage. We have > > > to agree that SM is a A list Hollywood movie, and the western > > > regonise him because of that. I personally believe most of the music > > > directors in India will get an oscar if they get a chance like AR. > > > Just that not all are blessed and blissfull as AR. just my view > > > > > > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, murali ramakrishnan > > > <dippythejammy@ > wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > Whatever "God wants to give noone can stop and if he decided to > > stop > > > > no one can give". > > > > > > > > I read an interesting article this week india today issue that > > > arr's father's resemblence is more in him > > > > and his dad used to buy lots of instrument even going to singapore > > > to get an instrument in those years itself. > > > > > > > > arr's dad died in mid 40's and arr has achieved this feat in the > > > same age which is marvellous to note > > > > and to note that whatever Rc shekar ,his dad aimed for arr has > > > achieved to day which we can feel it is > > > > the wish of God and his dad's blessings. > > > > > > > > one example his dad wanted to meet naushad,but naushad itself came > > > to chennai and blessed arr > > > > once roja released. > > > > > > > > msv another composer did not get recognition like ir received,is > > > that means he is not agr8 composer. > > > > > > > > awards are encouragement to an artist,if they wont get it does not > > > mean he is not good. > > > > > > > > though arr receives an award or not he is one of india's pride. > > > > > > > > whoever compares ir,msv with arr or arr with other md's i feel > > > sorry for their ignorance. > > > > > > > > all these three are pride of tamil film music. > > > > > > > > Murali, > > > > coimbatore > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > To: arrahmanfans@ : ravisdev@: Sun, 25 Jan 2009 07:42:19 > > > +0000Subject: Re: [arr] Suchi's comments on Radio One > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > I dont even the slightest dislike to composers who are original > > and > > > have put their great effort even on inspired songs & music, which > > > possible are very few in numbers. However its few fans (arrogant) > > who > > > tend to be blindfolded for their idol. In that case an AR's fan who > > > speaks deliberate rubbish is equally same as any others. Now let me > > > come back to the topic who claim IR had more chances of winning > > Oscar > > > or any other recognition. Please spare IR here. This matter should > > > only revolve with those who have the outburst speech. One question > > is > > > what made him not to win? Lets compare (not music, or their genius, > > > but pure phenomenon)IR was the first person to record (did he > > record, > > > OK conduct) a symphony in the Western soil with what not it was > > > Britain. He did symphonies in Budapest as well. Those places is > > > recognized as Vatican for western classical & Symphonies. And its > > for > > > sure there were ears which had analyzed, recognized and > > > recommended. IR was the first to get associated years ahead of AR > > with > > > the west. So where do you think he fell short. AR, many called him > > an > > > good sound Engr than music director. Spare their intelligence > > please. > > > There is sound everywhere but only few fall in the category of music > > > else its noise. What AR did was brought the good sound, etched the > > > music with engineering and elevated it to great heights. Again why > > > didn't IR get hooked to Oscar, spare Oscar what made him miss a > > > Grammy? He had wonderful independent albums. When Pt. Ravi Shankar , > > > Zakir Hussain did, why not IR? It was almost at the same time. AR is > > > recent, IR, Zakir & Pt. Ravishankar were in the same league. Why not > > > compare those? Why does somebody have to show their disappointment > > > (in a kind) of AR going to Oscars & GG rather than IR. Ask them to > > > check AR is not the only one who has surpassed in reality many did. > > > Now what makes AR getting recognized. As I had last written this man > > > reads the pulse, he thinks what can bring back the happiness in > > music > > > in a common man's ears. He knows classic, he learn technology, he > > > knows the world just because of no-ego factor in him, he is keen to > > > hear what a person wants. Obviously he brings what is liked. It > > > sounds different than others because he has a very unique > > > intelligence of combining all these. Where as his superiors only > > > concentrated on growing superior in one category. AR pumped the same > > > energy to all the categories which puts him ahead in the race. Many > > > termed his music was good in iPod & few said its best for dance > > > floor. But I being a simple listener had to listen to both the > > > comments from 2 individuals whereas I loved both, they were deaf to > > > recognize AR's versatility. So if Somebody is out to compare its > > just > > > them and nothing to do with AR or IR or RD Burman. --- In > > > arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, meena venkat <meenaunnimaya@ > wrote:>> > > > hmm .. she should have felt bad for the fact that ARR is getting > > this > > > recognition this late ! He must have won the award long back at > > least > > > for Lagaan , as it was in the list 4 Oscars .. !!!> Well IR is a > > > stalwart but then ARR is THE STALWART ! :)> > Rahmaniac> > > --- On > > > Sun, 1/25/09, Vithur <vithurm@> wrote:> > > From: Vithur <vithurm@>> > > > > Subject: Re: [arr] Suchi's comments on Radio One> > To: > > > arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com> > Date: Sunday, January 25, 2009, 8:20 > > > AM> > Dont get bogged down by all these.... Its the human tendency> > > > > > > to always think> > of something bad for someone, when somebody else > > > is> > achieving success.> > > > On Sun, Jan 25, 2009 at 12:39 AM, > > > maddy maddy> > <maddy2376@> wrote:> > > > > First of all Jai Ho to > > > Rahman sir. He gonna get us> > atleast 1 Oscar for> > > sure.> > >> > > > > > > > I was listening to Radio One 94.3 a day after AR sir> > got his > > > Oscar> > > nominations. The programme was Suchi sabha. Personally> > > > > I hate to hear this> > > show cos Suchi's way of speaking irritates > > > me.> > Since i was keen to hear as> > > to what she would say for AR > > > getting nominated (she is> > a big fan of IR) i> > > had to put up > > > with that irritating voice. In the> > programme She said that she> > > > > > was very much elated in hearing about sir's> > nomination but she > > > felt really> > > sad that IR did not get an international > > > recognition> > and started a call with> > > listeners asking them > > > which movie of IR would they> > give an Oscar to.> > >> > > Well i > > > have nothing to take away from IR since i was> > and i still am a > > > fan> > > of his music.> > >> > > Personally i thought this was > > > unnecessary of her. What> > do you guys think of> > > this? I need > > > your comments.> > >> > > > > >> > > > > > > > -- > > regards,> > > > > Vithur> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ____________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _ > > > > Wish to Marry Now? Join MSN Matrimony FREE! > > > > http://www.in. msn.com/matrimon y > > > > > > > >
