On 2/11/2009 11:36 AM India Time, _kishore parayath_ wrote: > Except for the EXCEPTIONAL INTERLUDE with SPECIAL STRING and CHORD > Coordination.. NOTHING is new or extraordinary in the WALL-E song... > Just another ordinary english song.... > > Whereas "Osaya" is a BRAND NEW concept from Rahman... Its like a new > SUB-GENRE inside pop.... Everything is FRESH and NEW in OSAYAA...... > > Osayaa is surely the BEST song....
That is it. I was also thinking on this line. Today, if any oscar jury has to pic an English Song to hear to, or vote to, which one would we pick? there are hundreds of great English songs that they must have liked and have enjoyed umpteenth time. Would it be father figure or careless whisper, or everything i do, or it must have been love, or quit playing games, or old - money, money, money, or latest heart will go on, and many more. So there. How much ever good it may be. It is good but it doesn't measure up to the standards of English music. But, when oscar jury hear that a song has emerged from the land of philosophy and peace and love and of tajmahal and is trying to reach the international audience, they are likely to help this song in its struggle, especially because there is a possibility that these songs and score could be a rare "single album wonder" by some whizkid and no other song or album comes this far in a long future. (It is not so, but get the possible flow of thoughts.) SDM has an emotional appeal. It is a survivor's movie. Anybody having seen it gets soft feelings towards the cast and towards the film. With this logic, I personally feel that Oscar voters would be in favor of SDM. -- Rawat
