Thanks Dinesh for your reply. I was also one of the active members but now a days I just read and go same as you. I request the members to observe decorum to the group. Please dont just blindly criticise musicians. Recently there was a bashing on Pyarelal was going on in this group just because he spoke his opinion. I cant take it also. Lakshmikant-Pyarelal pair have given us so many hit numbers in hindi. Also they composed for few tamil numbers. As a matter of tribute to them, even our ARR has composed 'Ring Ring Ringa' inspired from 'Choli Ke Peeche Kya Hai'. Again and again I request our group members to observe decorum of the group. Opinions are welcome but not bashing otherwise this group can be equated into a group without directions except bashing on people who speak otherwise. I also expect that people in this group will start bashing me for expressing my opinion. Anyway I have got people like you to speak your mind too in favour of what I express. I hope this makes sense and this group will continue to focus on ARR and his music. Thanks with regards, Mohamed Amin
--- On Wed, 3/4/09, Dinesh <[email protected]> wrote: From: Dinesh <[email protected]> Subject: Re: [arr] Ilayaraja hails Rahman as “phenomenal” To: [email protected] Date: Wednesday, March 4, 2009, 4:40 AM hey Mohamed Amin, i couldnt agree more with u about the members now days are rather rude towards some members when they speak something that the former doesnt like. its never the same like in the earlier 2000s. wonder where are those set of members went to. back in those days we can hardly see any members using sarcasm or using share words like nowdays. even becoz of this kind of attitudes in nowdays members in our group has made me limit my participation in this group.i used to be an active user here with the id "jeansdi". nowdays all i do is come here, read the news and leave. i do hope members of learn to respect and love our very own frends here. we r all brothers and sisters that r loving the same A.R.Rahman and his music. do not look down or ridicule any1 of them. thank u. --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Mohamed Amin <mymda...@.. .> wrote: > > Guys, > > please remember what ARR has advised his fans about not to condemn or write > ill of other musicians. > > No one can deny the genius of IR also. IR's story is also like the story of > Slumdog Millioinaire. Who in this group knows that during IR's first > recording the power went off. So what a rippling effect it could have been to > that man's confidence. Inspite of it, he rose and conquered the Tamil film > music. Do please remember that every person has their own talent. Its wrong > from our part to deroragete anyone. > > The primary purpose of this group is to discuss ARR's music but not to abuse > anyone else. We must give credit to good music where its due even its not > from ARR. > > As a person who in this group from the year 2000, I find lately that this > group is into bashing people whoever slightly speaks in different tune. Hope > all the members adhere to the recent advice by ARR. > > tks with regards, > Mohamed Amin > > > > > --- On Tue, 3/3/09, jayram.M.N <jayram...@. ..> wrote: > > From: jayram.M.N <jayram...@. ..> > Subject: Re: [arr] Ilayaraja hails Rahman as “phenomenal” > To: arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com > Date: Tuesday, March 3, 2009, 4:38 PM > > > > > > > There is nothing wrong in saying that every Tamilian is proud for ARR winning > an OSCAR. > > As a Tamilian I am proud of my language and proud of ARR for contributing so > much for Tamil music and world music. > > As an Indian I am proud of my country for accepting all languages and all > culture and all religion. > > These are not contradictory. > > Every one should be proud of his achievement. > > Jai Ho, Jay > > --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, V S Rawat <vsrawat@ > wrote: > > > > On 3/3/2009 8:56 PM India Time, _Vithur_ wrote: > > > > > He added that Rahman has made every Tamilian proud by winning two Oscars > > > in one year. > > > > Just "Tamilians"? > > > > Then, why the heck non-Tamil me have been feeling proud on ARR's Oscars? > > > > Why is IR so Tamil-centric? > > > > Hasn't he learned his lesson even now at this senior age that it was > > this Tamil-centric thinggy that didn't allow his great creativity to > > reach rest of the World. If he had gone beyond Tamil, I think IR would > > have got an Oscar much before ARR. > > > > -- > > Rawat > > >
