Not sure if Lucky Ali should have sung it, but i am sure a bunch of guys would have pounced on here and said that the song is similar to anjana anjani.....
On Sun, Sep 6, 2009 at 11:38 PM, Ashok Purohit <[email protected]>wrote: > > > Light5u, find my comments in blue to your email: > > Ashok brother, > Wel bro thats what u think that Lucky Ali will make a mistake N this is the > worst comment anyone can say about any singer. How can u say that without > knowing it ? Lucky Ali has sung many songs of such kind that it will be very > hard to sing for any other singer in the same manner (i m not saying that > any perticular singer will make a mistake). > > Light4u, chill down. If you read my mail carefully, all it means is that > anyone can make a mistake confusing Sukhi's notes in the beginning of Aaj > Dil with that of Lucky Ali. (and not Lucky Ali making a mistake, as you read > it, whatever your English meant) I am not sure what you read that made you > pounce on my email without any further reading. I respect all artists and > you must have never found any insenstive email from me in the last 10 years, > ever since I joined this community in 1999, confirm with Gops. I am > responsible for my statements and mature enough to think twice before > clicking on the SEND button, unlike many of people in here who recently > joined but are too quick to pull down otehr's email even before > understanding what it meant in the first place! > As far as Lucky Ali goes, I have myself been a very great fan of him ever > since Sunoh - not sure if you are aware that he also sang quite a few > masterpieces, including the one which was included in Bhopal Express (Tu > Kaun Hai) and the same track was later compiled with many versions in many > different pop compilations. Probably you are again mistaken as far as my > knowledge and liking for such a great singer goes. > > > If u haven't heard the 'Sunoh' album of Lucky Ali then please listen to it, > its an exceptional album till date. If I have to rate the best album of all > time in india it will be 'Sunoh' and 'Vande Matram'. I cant judge the best > among these two albums. If I like Lucky Ali that does not mean I will say > ill on Sukhwinder Singh. If u like Sukhwinder Singh u shouldnt say ill words > on Lucky Ali. By the way I like Sukhwinder a lot too. > Not sure what you meant in here and can you be specific where I have > specified about my liking more for Sukhi or Lucky? Please wake up and read > my mail carefully, I appeal. > > > I said Lucky Ali should have sung this song because 'Aaj dil gustakh hai' > is totally Lucky Ali's type of singing, genre N sukhwinder can sing in many > other kind of generes too. But defenatly L.A. would have sounded much better > than S.S. in this song. > I appreciate your thought. Its all personal opinion,so long you dont rip > down otehrs and respect everyone in this forum > > Guys please share ur views on this topic. > Everyone welcome. > > A humble appeal to everyone in this forum is that please keep up the ARR > forum standards as it has always been in the past. Of lately, quite a few > people (no offence meant to any one specifically) have been behaving > possessively about this group making it a personal space to share. All I am > requesting for is to be polite, respectful and clear in your emails and take > time to understand and respect other fans point of view. Art is a subjective > topic to discuss and open mindedness is all that makes a positive > difference. > > Thanks and Vande Mataram, > Ashok > > > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Are you searching for a reason, to be kind? > <b> > Explore, Experience, Enjoy A.R.Rahman - The Man, The Music, The Magic. > Only at arrahmanfans.com - The definitive A.R.Rahman e-community. > > Homepage: http://www.arrahmanfans.com > Admin: [email protected]<http://mc/[email protected]> > To Subscribe: > [email protected]<http://mc/[email protected]> > To Unsubscribe: > [email protected]<http://mc/[email protected]>! > Groups Links > > > > > ------------------------------ > Love Cricket? Check out live scores, photos, video highlights and more. Click > here <http://in.rd.yahoo.com/tagline_cricket_2/*http://cricket.yahoo.com>. > > >
