On 9/12/2009 12:19 PM India Time, _Arijit Debnath_ wrote: > > > Just heard one of the worst songs in my lifetime 'Chali Aai'.... but got > no resembles of 'yaar mila tha'.... except both are in 'keherba' taal in > 8 beats... wasted my time in listening to 'chali aai'..sad incident... > � > Arijit
my goodness, you understand all these taal and beats? great! btw, why is "both being in 'keherba' taal in 8 beats" not a good prompting criterion that a song would remind of another song based on same things? It was a situation like ID's song in Kisna "kaahe ujaadi mori neend" kept on reminding me something and then I figured that it is prompting to Naushad saab's Mughal-e-azam song "prem jogan ban ke", and then some learned member in this group clarified that both are based on exactly the same raga, (subhash ghai might have insisted on it, the way he is) Anyway. In spite of you wasting too many words in condemning and tarnishing one of the finer creations of Anu Malik, I still thank you for clarifying it to me as I could not have understood it on my own. Hope you don't go listening to the above mentioned Kisna and MeA songs as none is by ARR and your time will be wasted. -- Rawat > > 2009/9/9 V S Rawat <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> > > � > > Whenever I am hearing Yaar Mila tha, somehow Anu Malik song from the > movie Main Prem Ki Diwani Hu, "Chali Aai, Chali Aayi, Dil Ne bahut > roka" > or something like that, keeps on coming to my mind. > > I have not heard that song in years, not after a month or so after the > film release, I have not seen the film, but I did find that song very > catchy when I had head that then. > > I have no knowledge about technical aspects of songs and music - > instruments, beats, loops, whatever, so I am not able to place this > prompting. Can anyone describe why is it so. > > -- > Rawat
