On 9/28/2009 11:19 AM India Time, _Jesheem Mohamed_ wrote: > It definitely is a wonderful soundtrack and that too for a debut album.
Indeed. Very much true. It was innovative, catchy without having cheap "mass" music. Nimbuda, Dholi had great chorus, simple expressive lyrics, a folk-sy feel. My fav is Tadap Tapad ke is dil se, that would do any MD proud, including ARR. what a pain, what a pathos, and above all what a range. That is a song that highlights that ARR doesn't go beyond a fixed boundary to express feelings, ARR does keep an elegance and decorum in his songs which doesn't gel well with extremes of emotions when people are least bothered about decorum and are just wishing to express their feeling in the raw-est methods without inhibitions. ARR should try to give a song like Tadap Tadap Ke. While thinking about this "boundaries maintained by ARR", I think blue's Yaar Mila Tha is also suffering from this forced elegance and decorum that it did not become a real chulbula, naughty, chhedchhad song likes of which many MDs have given that really bring a soft smile at your lips. Apart from this praise of HDDCS... > But to say that it has never been toppled by ARR is definitely a > debatable topic. right. Absolutely correct. Not just ARR but many others MDs of recent times have given equally good or even better albums. At most, it can be said that ID himself could never give anything better than HDDCS -- Rawat > > Here's a thread. Leaving out every single album, I doubt if the Music > connoisseurs CAN ignore *Jodha Akbar*! JA was a musical masterpiece. > People who were then a lil unsure abt the grand music, definitely will > understand the value it added in bringing out the aesthetics of each and > every scene. A soundtrack that did justice not just to the movie but as > well for the period it was set in, it still had a dimension that was way > ahead of times. > > I strongly believe that JA has to be the strongest contender for > soundtrack at the 2008 National Awards. > > Any thoughts to ponder? > > Cheers.. > Jesheem > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > To: [email protected] > From: [email protected] > Date: Mon, 28 Sep 2009 00:43:51 +0000 > Subject: [arr] Anyone agree with this statement from PB? > > > http://www.planetbollywood.com/displayReview.php?id=m092709044147 > <http://www.planetbollywood.com/displayReview.php?id=m092709044147> > > Check out the last line: > > "In short, most music connoisseurs out there will agree that Ismail > Darbar's debut soundtrack has never been toppled since its release, not > by Darbar himself, not by Bhansali and not even by the greatest musician > of our time, the Oscar winning A.R.Rahman�....as such HDDCS takes it's > place in the annals of history as a true classic of the modern era. An > unforgettable masterpiece!" > > I agree it's a great soundtrack....one of the best in the modern era of > Hindi film music, but better than anything ARR has come out with since > its release? Hmmmmmm......worthy of debate for sure! > > > > > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > Get easy photo sharing with Windows Live� Photos. Drag n� drop > <http://www.microsoft.com/india/windows/windowslive/photos.aspx> > >
