Thank you Doug.
It had to be manual because not all was corrupted, only 10 of 15, didnot know which ones had the issue. I kept the old as record, and made notes in the Change history of each changed, and tracked with Service tickets. We get audited for change alot; so document document. Agreed, the groups in question - there is no record of them every existing. The administrator who managed this has been doing this since we had Remedy version 2 coming forward. He does not remove groups; actually single source. This workflow have been in the system since 2005, last modified for most so before me i start in 2007. We are not sure what happen at the time a customer reported the issue of the menus not loading correctly. I just happen to try recreating one active to resolve the issue and happen on the group errors. No import to modify the active link was done, however, within the last 2 weeks menus loaded by the actives link was either imported/modified on fly. Our test environment mirrors production, with the same workflow (these are processes that have not changed in a very long time). At the very least test has more workflow for new fields and processes; but group info don't change much. The groups list in the corrupted active links, still exist today in all environments. its if i try to find 47, 107, 119 - which i see no reference anywhere. Per my co-worker, groups are not deleted. And , Yes, all users of Change have access to the activelinks. Same amount on permission, these active links average out with 70 attached permissions. This is inherited because as I develop - they really only need one group Change permission to access those fields which is how i recreated.. I thought of that, that not same name but same ID for the group, but in this case test and prod are most similar. Looking at the groups form, there are 3 new groups not in test; none with the ids being flagged in the error. 2 groups that are the same, only license allocation being manipulated. Only 5 modified year to date for production. As you say, I presume they may have existed before; but no record. (side track) - We had an ongoing issue since 2009 (3 cases with BMC, no solution) on the same form for attachments on the MT, non-admin on create the initial attachment is not appended to the record. I alway thought is was permission issue also. Well this week, that miraculously resolved it self also on test/prod. So, I have 2 mysteries, Is there a scan that can be ran - to check all workflow and fields for group errors? DEE -----Original Message----- From: Mueller, Doug <[email protected]> To: arslist <[email protected]> Sent: Wed, Sep 25, 2013 3:56 pm Subject: Re: Active links to change menu on field is not working ** Dee, If you have not finished modifying the active links, please export the existing definition of ones you are modifying and then modify them. So, you have a record. When you have an active link (or anything with permissions), you can define permissions, but they have to be to legal, actual groups that exist. You will get errors if you assign permissions to a non-group. BUT, if groups change (are deleted for example), we do not invalidate existing definitions. They just keep working with the group that is not valid being ignored. So, you have a definition in your system which has an "error" in it that we ignore. If you later open the definition and then try and save it, the system notes that you have groups referenced that don't exist and it removes them as it will get an error on save. It gives you the warning you are seeing in the message to let you know that it is doing this cleanup. Then, the save happens with no problem. So, the system is doing the cleanup automatically but warning you of the permission issue it is fixing. By the way, import has an exception that it allows "bad" groups as it assumes you just haven't gotten around to importing them yet. So, again, you can get permissions that exist on a dev box in the definition but those same groups don't exist on prod so if you modify the def on prod you could be seeing warnings about dev groups referenced that you never moved to prod. Now, none of that should be related to the logic not working. Unless people are in different groups on dev and prod β like the missing 3 groups called out here? Why I wanted you to save the definitions before fixing them was to see what the permissions were. Do your users have access to the active link? Are there permissions other than these three groups that do give the users access or is there some kind of a group mismatch between dev and prod? Remember, you may be seeing the same name as we show names in the UI, but if the ID behind the scenes for the groups is different on dev and prod, they are really different groups as we match everything on the ID even though we show you the name. Those groups did exist somewhere at some time. They could have been gone for many years β you just never modified the workflow so you never got to the cleanup step. Now, the only reason that things could suddenly stop working should be a permission change or something just blocked the workflow from the user. Hopefully, we can backtrack if we have original definitions as to the cause. I would also confirm that you have the same groups on dev and prod and that they have the same IDs. Doug Mueller From: Action Request System discussion list(ARSList) [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of DEE Sent: Wednesday, September 25, 2013 11:20 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: Active links to change menu on field is not working ** This is what I have found, All the active links that are doing a Change menu, based on selecting a CATEGORY then the appropriate Menu is attachment to ITEM, seem to be corrupted. On modifying one of the Active Link, I got the following error of missing/removed group id 47, 107, 119. (See attachment). To combat this i'm recreating the active links, and this is resolving the production issue (at the moment). However, these groups never existed as far as i know. The workflow is the same on test (copy of production) and groups. Groups are not deleted ( verified by admin). So, what could have corrupted these specific active links, and not others? why is it looking groups that don't exist? (any hint would be great). -----Original Message----- From: DEE <[email protected]> To: arslist <[email protected]> Sent: Wed, Sep 25, 2013 9:34 am Subject: Re: Active links to change menu on field is not working (Original Post with additions) Environment: BIGIP (F5) 2 servers -Websphere 6.1 http cluster on UNIX 6.1.7 2 servers -Websphere 6.1 jvm cluster on UNIX 6.1.7 1 server -ARS 7.5 Patch 4 with local 11g DB on Unix 6.1.7 We have a custom change form that include the following fields Change Category Change Item Based on your change category selection, an active link with load the appropriate menu to Change Item. It was reported yesterday that this function is not working. Now this has been functioning fine for the last 7 years (when I inherited Remedy). Points: 1. This is not happening with Admins 2. This is happen for non-admin users. 3. At first it seems like it was only affect non-admin users with floating licenses, but a second test of users dispel that symptom 4. This is occurring in the User tool (7.6.04 Sp3) and MT (7.5.000 Patch 004) 5. This is occurring in browsers, IE8, FireFox 23.0.1, Chrome 29.0.1547.76 6. Initially thought it was a MT issue, flushed cache etc. 7. This is not occurring in our test environment, User tool (7.6.04 Sp3) & MT (7.5.000 Patch 004) / MT (7.6.4 SP5) & ARS 7.5 Patch 8. All characters have been removed from the menu items (+, &, (), ', ,, ...) We have not made any changes to the production environment. the workflow, the menus was modified at least 2 weeks ago. Per the webadmins, no change the web sphere infrastructure. Window 7 desktop was recently patched, however, I tested on a machine that did have the patches in the last 2 weeks applied, issue exist there, too. DBA verified no patches or adhoc changes to db. She was able to verify that T51 and views are fine. She see no errors in the log. This is only happening on 1 form, Change form. There are 423 directly related objects. The issue is haphazard, for my test id, non-admin, All menus loaded, except one menu that is very large (Large enough to be a form; unfortunately process and ownership issue) - the workflow for that particular activelink, does not get calculated. for my co-work, remedy admin also, None of the menus load. He describes the default CHANGE ITEM menu, if the only one that is loading. - which indicates that the workflow for the active link in not working. What could cause active links, not to fire correctly? Is there a limit to amount of menu items? -----Original Message----- From: Young, Ronald P. <[email protected]> To: arslist <[email protected]> Sent: Wed, Sep 25, 2013 9:26 am Subject: Re: Active links to change menu on field is not working ???? Thanks, Ron Young βTo the world you may be one person but to one person you may be the world.β -----Original Message----- From: Action Request System discussion list(ARSList) [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Dee Sent: Wednesday, September 25, 2013 7:45 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: Active links to change menu on field is not working In addition, DBA verified no patches or adhoc changes to db. She was able to verify that T51 and views are fine. She see no errors in the log. This is only happening on 1 form, Change form. There are 423 directly related objects. _______________________________________________________________________________ UNSUBSCRIBE or access ARSlist Archives at www.arslist.org "Where the Answers Are, and have been for 20 years" _______________________________________________________________________________ UNSUBSCRIBE or access ARSlist Archives at www.arslist.org "Where the Answers Are, and have been for 20 years" _ARSlist: "Where the Answers Are" and have been for 20 years_ _ARSlist: "Where the Answers Are" and have been for 20 years_ _______________________________________________________________________________ UNSUBSCRIBE or access ARSlist Archives at www.arslist.org "Where the Answers Are, and have been for 20 years"

