<<<without this Hindus cannot survive in Bharat.>>>>

Go ahead Hindu!

Doesn't concern the Assamese.

mm



From: "Rini Kakati" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: [email protected], [EMAIL PROTECTED],[EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Subject: [Assam] Fwd: The minorities in Bharat can't become the waves ofmainstream
Date: Mon, 23 Jan 2006 14:27:29 +0000

From: "Mohan Gupta" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject: The minorities in Bharat can't become the waves of mainstream
Date: Mon, 23 Jan 2006 00:46:17 -0500

The minorities in Bharat can't become the waves of mainstream

What has constituted our constitution is just opposite to its preamble. It does not ensure social justice neither it has been adopted by the people of Bharat. At the time of independence our level of thought was influenced by so many factors including the riots caused by the bifurcation India. We had that time no other option than to adopt a constitution hap-hazardly as an independent nation at least requires a format of procedures. The history of Bharat is also of a different nature. When Islam was not there in our country before 600 AD what was our status. We were divided into so many fractions and the kingdoms and provinces were involved in attaining more and more power ruthlessly. It just did not help the poor section of the society which was the mass. So the elitism in itself had the roots of stratification. The deprived section of the society was eagerly waiting not for a constitution for a change in the social system. But unfortunately the invasion by the Arabs completely changed the very structure of the society. The Muslims became rulers and after the decline of the Mughals in the early nineteenth century the Muslims had a good proportion in Bharatiya population. So during the rule of the Arabs, the Sultanate and the Mughals itself the Muslims were in a privileged position. They were appointed Nazirs and Mansabdars in huge numbers. But unfortunately with the British rule everything changed. Hindus were now in a better position and they adopted the modern system of education introduced by the British. They became more liberal and developed a democratic sense. The Muslims remained out of this mainstream and more conservative. It does not matter whether we get a religious privilege from the Govt. or not. It is to be decided by the minorities and Muslims of the country whether they just want such special privileges or they want to assimilate themselves in the mainstream of Indian society. I think the Muslims of this country should demand for the uniform code and not the special privileges for Muslims, because in a way they are losing more and gaining less by such provisions. They are still limited to a small boundary and if they are still demanding an institution for them only they would not be able to give their life a vast dimension and their way of life would never change according to the standards of the modern world. I appeal them to follow the chant- Aa No Bhadrah Kratvo Yantu Vishvatah. (Let the noble thoughts come to us from every side of the world.) I do not think that all the Muslims should be treated alike and we should follow the ideas of those people only who are more liberal. And we should also not look in the conservative ideas of any religion because if we would remain thinking in that perspective there would not be any change. However it’s of course a matter of surprise that the lawmakers of India still believe that minorities are helpless and they can't become the waves of mainstream. In other words the constitution is not treating the minorities as special but as an untouchable. We should try to educate every section of the society and when there will be education every where no one will demand for reservations and privileges and quotas.

----

Constitutional communalism?

 

Charti Lal Goel

 

http://www.dailypioneer.com/archives2/default12.asp?main_variable=oped&file_name=opd2%2Etxt&counter_img=2&phy_path_it=F%3A%5Cdailypioneer%5Carchives2%5Csep2304

 

(Charti Lal Goel is a former Speaker of Delhi Vidhan Sabha and Member of the Central BSP Intellectual Cell)

 

As per its preamble, the Indian Constitution stands for a secular state. The state has no official religion. Secularism pervades its provision, which gives full opportunity to all persons to profess, practice and propagate any religion of their choice. It also ensures freedom for one who has no religion and it scrupulously restrains the State from discriminating on the grounds of religion. Dr S Radhakrishnan, former President of India, writes in his book Recovery of Faith (p 184), "We hold that not one religion should be given preferential status." Prohibition against discrimination on grounds of religion is incorporated in Articles 15 and 16 of the constitution, as quoted below. Article 15(1): The State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of religion, race, cast, sex, and place of birth or any of them. Article 16(2): No citizen shall, on grounds only of religion, be ineligible for, or discriminated against, in respect of any employment or office under the state. It is very strange and also unfortunate that the constitution of India itself has harmed its sanctity by making a discriminatory and contradictory provision under Article 30 in the name of the protection of minority interests. Article 30 reads: "Right of minorities to establish and administer educational institutions: (i) All minorities, whether based on religion or language, shall have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice." Under these Articles certain privileges and special rights have been given to religious minorities to establish and administer their educational institutions. Why have these very rights and privileges not been given to all religions? Heaven would not have fallen if all religions had been treated alike. Followers of all religions want to protect their culture and establish and administer institutions. I do not think that the framers of the constitution desired that only the religions of minorities should flourish and that those of the majority should be slowly extinguished. In my opinion this is where the seeds of divide and separatism have been sown between religions in India. Hindus have many ways of worship and are divided into many sects. There are Jains, Buddhists, Radha soawmi, followers of Ram Krishna Paramhans, etc. Due to the special privileges given to religious minorities by the Constitution, a number of Hindu sects have started claiming a status of minority. It has resulted in creating a schism and bad feelings among the different sects. It should be a cause of concern for every person interested in the unity of the country. This has also given birth to the idea that in discriminating in favour of a minority you still remain secular as per the Constitution. There is an other very illogical and disturbing development in the country with regard to secularism. The rights of every citizen need to be protected. If some individual or organisation comes forward for the protection of any right or situation concerning Hindus then it is called communal. But if anything is said in protection of any right or situation pertaining to Muslims then it remains a perfectly secular cause. So much so that a Muslim defending a hard-core Muslim terrorist retains his image of a perfect Secularist. If political parties have an alliance with the Muslim League, which under its constitution accepts only Muslims as members, then they are called secular. But the BJP, which has Muslims as its All India office bearers, is still termed communal. The Human Rights Commission is also very quick to ask for immediate reports when Muslim terrorists are killed by the police or armed forces in an encounter. Sadly, the same Human Rights Commission does not take sue motto notice if Hindus are killed either in Kashmir or anywhere else. The Commission is also not bothered if Muslim women are treated treacherously and cruelly by their husbands who can renounce them by saying "talak" three times for fear of antagonising the Mullah. This shows an obvious bias and discrimination all around. If the Shahi Imam issues `fatwa' calling upon Muslims to vote in favour of political parties, it is not communal. If Sadhu-Sanyasis suggest voting for a party which looks after Hindu interests they are termed communal. If MF Husain, the renowned painter, shows disrespect to Hindu gods and goddess in his paintings, it remains an art. Conversely, The Satanic Verses is banned because some Mullahs objected to the book. Such a lopsided development is possible because of the discrimination initially laid down in the Constitution under Articles 29 and 30. If the country wishes to take the path of genuine and truthful secularism, there must be an amendment in the constitution - either by deleting the provision of Article 30, or by giving the rights and privileges contained therein to people of all other religions as well.

            Our secular leaders are scared to utter a word against Muslim leaders for fear of life and if Hindus react aggressively then they Muslim will have second thought before they attack Hindu sentiments. Hindus need militancy to counter attack on Hindus and Hinduism and without this Hindus cannot survive in Bharat.
======================

 



MSN Premium gives you PC protection, junk-mail filters, advanced communication tools and great software like MSN Encarta® Premium. Click here for a FREE trial!

>_______________________________________________
>assam mailing list
>[email protected]
>http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org

_______________________________________________
assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org

Reply via email to