|
Dear Rajen, Ram and Umesh,
As regards hereditary caste system, please consider the frollowing few points:
Out of many verses of Rikveda, the famous twelfth verse of the Purusha Sukta of Rikveda sounds non-typical: brahmana asya
mukham asit bahu rajanyakah kritah ubdha tat asya
yad vaishyah padbhyam sudrah ajayata brahmin became his mouth, kshatriya (became his) arms, vaishya (became his) thighs, sudra was born from the feet The distinctive use of the words became (asit) and born (ajayata) indicates that this verse is not typical of most of the allegorical descriptions in Rik Veda verses. Some scholars [I am still seeking the reference] opine that this verse was added to Rik Veda at a later time by interested parties. On the other hand, the creation of the castes is described in a different way in Shatapatha Brahmana (2/10/11) or Taittiriya Brahmana (3/12/9/2) where the sudra caste is not mentioned at all. More accurately, at another place in Rik Veda (9/112), we hear the rishi : job of all persons cannot be the same. A carpenter straightens wood, a physician looks after a patient, and a singer seeks the priest. Look at me ! I am a hymn-writer, my son is a physician, and my daughter is a cook Bhagavadgita is absolutely clear (4/13) that the four castes were created according to guna and karma (aptitude and job) definitely not according to birth. The verses 41-44 in chapter 18 are description of the different natural aptitudes of different people, not a justification of the hereditary caste system. A Brahmin, the so called highest caste of Hindus, is defined as a person with a heart as pure as a newborn baby. This proves that all newborn babies are Brahmin. This is supported by the verse in Mahabharata (Shanti Parva Chapter 188): na visheshah
brahmana
purvasristam hi karmabhih varnatam gatam There is nothing so special about the hereditary castes. At the beginning, everyone is a Brahmin. Castes come up later according to job. One thousand years before Mahabharata and Bhagavadgita,
Chandogya Upanishad carried the wonderful story of Satyakama where an
illegitimate son of a slave woman was accepted as a brahmin. Later Satyakama
became the principal hymn writer in Chandogya Upanishad. His disciple,
Upakoshal, saw the famous truth Sky is Love yadeva kham tadeva kam iti.
GROUND
REALITY OF HEREDITARY CASTE SYSTEM TODAY:
In spite of all scriptural clarification, Hindus in The causes of hereditary caste system appear to be the same as those of racialism all over the world. In modern
I think Inter-caste marriage, based on love and commitment between the couples, will eliminate the twin-headed monster of hereditary caste system and dowry system in India.
With the best wishes, Himendra
|
_______________________________________________ assam mailing list [email protected] http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
