|
I will agree with you. My only
point was that caste system was hereditary even in the past. Unless some proves
otherwise, let us accept it and proceed.
Nobody is blaming the Brahmins.
Brahmins did not start the caste system. In fact I am of the opinion that
the practice caste system is more in the lower castes. But the Brahmins had
their role. The lower caste can take control of things if they want
to.
I will give an example. Lower
castes will complain why only he Brahmins are allowed to take the
'logun'.
My answer is why the lower castes
start taking 'logun' by their own appointed Brahmin and start writing
Sarma, Goswami as their title? In stead of complaining Why the lower castes do
something? Why the lower castes don't stop hiring Brahmin priest for their
sraddha etc? Nobody is preventing them.
But I know the answer why they
cannot.
RB
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Friday, March 24, 2006 11:23
AM
Subject: Re: [Assam] Hereditary Caste
System in India
>*** No wonder therefore, the hereditary caste-system is at par with
all of them
>who did and still do practise racism!
Hope you all don't mind my butting in.
What have these crafty Brahmins done now?
This thing about heredity is NOT confined just to Brahmins, is it?
Lets look:
Assamese don't (normally) marry outside their language. Heck they don't
even marry other Assamese known as Kukis, Ahoms or Koch, Boros -
exceptions don't prove the rule.
Most Assamese don't marry below their caste (and we are not talking about
Brahmins only here)
And this phenomenon is NOT just confined to Assamese. Its done and redone
all over India (including our educated NRAs and other NRIs).
So, what does all this point out? Every damn thing is hereditary. If you
are born Bengali, you confine yourself to marring another Bengali. If you born
a Kalita (or a Mahanta) its unlikely they will marry below their caste or
language.
Exceptions aside, we are all 'guilty' of being extensions of traditions
and heredity. Why are we singling out only the Brahmins here?
How many of us (on this net) can claim NOT to be tied down by extensions
of traditions or heredity? Once again netters see this thinly veiled
garb, holier than thou rear its head.
--Ram
On 3/24/06, Chan
Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>One thousand years before
Mahabharata and Bhagavadgita, Chandogya Upanishad carried the
wonderful story of Satyakama where an illegitimate son of a slave
woman was accepted as a brahmin. Later Satyakama became the
principal hymn writer in Chandogya Upanishad. His disciple,
Upakoshal, saw the famous truth "Sky is Love" yadeva kham tadeva
kam iti.
*** No I don't think that is what I read Rajen. If the anecdote is
accurate ( forgive the oxymoron nature of the point ) , then the 'slave
woman' --who not a Brahmin, gave birth to the illegitimate Satyakam, who was
accepted as a Brahmin.
But you are right that it does not tell anyone WHY Satykam was accepted
as a Brahmin. Perhaps because the man who sired him was a Brahmin? Certainly
not on his own merit, which became known only much later, when he became the
principal hymn-writer. Which of course vindicated those who accepted him as
a Brahmin to begin with. The anecdote was recorded probably for the
vindication of those who committed the transgression ( more than likely
wayward Brahmin supporters of the wild-oats sowing father) of accepting
Satyakam as a Brhmin, in spite of being born of a 'slave',
>In spite of all scriptural clarification,
Hindus in India cannot get rid of the immovable yoke of hereditary caste
system. It is very important to study the cause.
>The
causes of hereditary caste system appear to be the same as those of
racialism all over the world.
*** No wonder therefore, the hereditary caste-system is at par with all
of them who did and still do practise racism!
What is your problem Rajen :-)?
At 10:38 AM -0600 3/24/06, Rajen Barua wrote:
<One thousand years
before Mahabharata and Bhagavadgita, Chandogya Upanishad carried the
wonderful story of Satyakama where an illegitimate son of a slave woman
>was accepted as a brahmin. Later Satyakama became the principal hymn
writer in Chandogya Upanishad. His disciple, Upakoshal, saw the famous
truth "Sky is Love" >yadeva kham tadeva kam
iti.>
Funny
thing is do you know what is the fallacy even of this one
example.
The
fallacy is the SON is accepted as a BRAHMIN because HIS MOTHER, a slave
woman, MUST BE A BRAHMIN BECAUSE SHE WAS TELLING THE
TRUTH.
The son
was not accepted as a Brahmin because of his own merit, but because of his
mother's merit.
So this
prove that a BRAHMIN'S SON IS A BRAHMIN.
That is
the hole I was talking about.
I wonder
why Hindu scholars donot see this hole in the example?
Again,
let someone prove me dumb and wrong.
Rajen
----- Original Message -----
From: Chan
Mahanta
To: Rajen
Barua
Cc: [email protected]
Sent: Friday, March 24, 2006 10:27 AM
Subject: Re: [Assam] Hereditary Caste System in
India
But Rajen,
<One thousand years before
Mahabharata and Bhagavadgita, Chandogya Upanishad carried the wonderful
story of Satyakama where an illegitimate son of a slave woman was
accepted as a brahmin. Later Satyakama became the principal hymn writer
in Chandogya Upanishad. His disciple, Upakoshal, saw the famous truth
"Sky is Love" yadeva kham tadeva kam iti.>
*** Don't you get it? Isn't that a perfect example of the
REAL Hinduism's goodness?
Now don't go about arguing that it is one in a million
exception to the rule.
In fact I will add one more fine example: President Kalam
was adopted by Tamil Brahmins--and look what he turned out to be! Will
you take issue with that too?
<A Brahmin, the so called
highest caste of Hindus, is defined as a person with a heart as
pure as a newborn baby. This proves that all newborn babies are
Brahmin.>
*** See, another awesome bit of reasoning here. Again it is
them bad guys who would not allow, even the BRAHMIN newborn of a Dalit
to enter a temple, no doubt guarded against invasion by untouchables by
people with hearts as pure as those of the newborn--Brahmin priests.
<In modern India, democracy is
ruined by caste-oriented vote-banks practiced by the political
parties. >
*** And mind you, these are of a PARTICULARly nasty ilk of
politicians! Take a wild guess on WHO they are!
Very, very skeptically yours,
c :-)
At 9:28 AM -0600 3/24/06, Rajen Barua wrote:
Himenda:
I am yet to find
a Hindu scholar who would say that Caste was hereditary in past.
Everybody, starting from Radhaksrishnan and all, try to defend the
position that the caste system was actually NOT hereditary in the past
citing examples like you did.
But till now
nobody could convince me that it was NOT hereditary. Frankly speaking
I can see the holes in the very examples you cited. I think all the
Hindu scholars will call me a dumb guy, but I always ask the following
dumb question to the defenders of the case to prove that the caste
system was NOT hereditary in the past:
Question:
If caste system
was NOT hereditary at some point in the past, then there must have
been a system in vogue sometime in the past to regulate the caste
system so that it does not become hereditary. A system like say at the
age of (5, 10, 12 you name it) the boy or girl is taken to a test
(like the Mandarins in China) where they are tested and someone is
declaring "OK, you become a Brahmin, you become a Sudra
etc.' If you think carefully, without such a Mandarin
system in vogue, caste system will have to be hereditary.
Now out of the
million written words, stories, upakhyans in so many Hindu Kabya,
Mahalkbaya, Purans etc can anyone can show me one single incident
which will indicate that such a system ever existed in India.
So far nobody
could show me. But there may be such instances. But as I told you I am
a dumb guy. Show me where is the beef.
I think we should
accept whatever it was in the past and move on. But we should not try
to defend something which is not true.
But I amy be
wrong. I would like to see someone proving that I am
wrong.
That will be an
enlightenment.
Rajen
Barua
From: Himendra
Thakur
To: Barua25 ; Ram Sarangapani ;
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] ; [email protected]
Sent: Thursday, March 23, 2006 10:02
PM
Subject: Hereditary Caste System in
India
Dear Rajen, Ram and
Umesh,
As regards hereditary caste
system, please consider the frollowing few
points:
Out of many verses of
Rikveda, the famous twelfth verse of the Purusha Sukta of Rikveda
sounds non-typical:
brahmana asya mukham
asit bahu rajanyakah kritah
ubdha tat asya yad vaishyah
padbhyam sudrah ajayata
"brahmin became his mouth,
kshatriya (became his) arms, vaishya (became his) thighs, sudra was
born from the feet" …
The distinctive use of the
words "became" (asit) and "born" (ajayata) indicates
that this verse is not typical of most of the allegorical
descriptions in Rik Veda verses. Some scholars [I am still seeking
the reference] opine that this verse was added to Rik Veda at a
later time by interested parties. On the other hand, the creation of
the castes is described in a different way in Shatapatha Brahmana
(2/10/11) or Taittiriya Brahmana (3/12/9/2) where the sudra caste is
not mentioned at all.
More accurately, at
another place in Rik Veda (9/112), we hear the rishi
:
" … job of all persons cannot
be the same. A carpenter straightens wood, a physician looks
after a patient, and a singer seeks the priest. Look at me ! I
am a hymn-writer, my son is a physician, and my daughter is a cook
…"
Bhagavadgita is absolutely
clear (4/13) that the four castes were created according to
guna and karma (aptitude and job) … definitely not
according to birth. The verses 41-44 in chapter 18 are description
of the different natural aptitudes of different people, not a
justification of the hereditary caste system.
A Brahmin, the so called
highest caste of Hindus, is defined as a person with a heart as
pure as a newborn baby. This proves that all newborn babies are
Brahmin. This is supported by the verse in Mahabharata (Shanti Parva
Chapter 188):
na visheshah asti varnanam
sarvam bhahmam idam jagat
brahmana purvasristam hi
karmabhih varnatam gatam
"There is nothing so special
about the hereditary castes. At the beginning, everyone is a
Brahmin. Castes come up later according to
job."
One thousand years before
Mahabharata and Bhagavadgita, Chandogya Upanishad carried the
wonderful story of Satyakama where an illegitimate son of a slave
woman was accepted as a brahmin. Later Satyakama became the
principal hymn writer in Chandogya Upanishad. His disciple,
Upakoshal, saw the famous truth "Sky is Love" yadeva kham tadeva
kam iti.
GROUND REALITY OF HEREDITARY
CASTE SYSTEM TODAY:
In spite of all scriptural
clarification, Hindus in India cannot get rid of the immovable yoke
of hereditary caste system. It is very important to study the
cause.
The causes of hereditary caste
system appear to be the same as those of racialism all over the
world.
In modern India, democracy is
ruined by caste-oriented vote-banks practiced by the political
parties. Unimaginable violence and cruelty are committed in the name
of caste. Dowry system, that causes bride-burning in many cases,
flourishes in the system of arranged marriage, which is a direct
consequence of hereditary caste system.
I think Inter-caste marriage,
based on love and commitment between the couples, will eliminate the
twin-headed monster of hereditary caste system and dowry system in
India.
With the best
wishes,
Himendra
----- Original Message -----
From: umesh
sharma
To: Rajen Barua ;
Ram
Sarangapani
Cc: [email protected]
Sent: Thursday, March 23, 2006 11:06
AM
Subject: Re: [Assam] HPI, March 20,
2006
Rajen-da,
Even this verse by itself doesnot say that Brahmin is
by birth - it merely states that Brahmins are intellectuals (from
head or brain) - thus does show that intellect is superior to
other things - if you believe that one part of human body is more
important than others. Kshatriya is said to come from arms -
denoting strength -used for fighting -does not say about
hereditary caste system.
On the other hand it speaks of cohesion - in the sense
that all people in any soicety are doing equally important work -
just as parts of a human body - regardless of their social status.
I repeat - no mention of hereditary caste system.
Umesh
Rajen Barua <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
I think it is the
Gita.
I will
check
Rajenda
----- Original Message -----
From: umesh
sharma
To: Rajen
Barua ; Ram
Sarangapani
Cc: [email protected]
Sent: Thursday, March 23, 2006 9:37
AM
Subject: Re: [Assam] HPI, March 20,
2006
I do recall that there is such a verse but I do
not recall seeing it in Geeta or that Krishna said
it.
Umesh
Rajen Barua <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
wrote:
I will
have to read the verse in detail. I think Krishna states
bothways:
Those
who are born out of my head are the
Brahmins
Those
who are born out of my shoulder, are the
Kshatriyas.
Those
who are born out of my stomach are the
Vaishya.
Those
who are born out of my feet are the
Sudras.
Can you
check if above is true.
Rajenda
_______________________________________________ assam
mailing list [email protected] http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
_______________________________________________ assam
mailing list [email protected] http://assamnet.org/mailman/listinfo/assam_assamnet.org
|