*** First, I think Sanjay Hazarika's dismissal of the Sentinel Editorial's thrust on account of some other past editorial which was not well deliberated or was simply unimaginative, is NOT at all persuasive.His charges of it being hysterical is an effort at discrediting it without offering the readers any explanation of why it is so.
I don't know whether the charges made by the Sentinel are factual. I have no way of verifying. But the fact that these are serious charges, against the Judiciary, the only branch of the Nation's governance that still holds a semblance of credibility, leads me to think that the Sentinel charges could NOT be either fabrication or blown out of proportion. Since no one has proven otherwise, we have to use this as a basis for the discussion. Hazarika did not challenge the Sentinel's charges and therby ignored its ramifications. Ramifications that are extremely important in view of two decades of insurgency that has savaged the lives of a people, OUR people. Had the institutions of democracy functioned in India, India and the NE would not be in the shape it is today. The Judiciary is a critical part of those essential institutions of democracy. If the highest echelons of the judiciary is as cavalier and cynical about its role and its responsibilities, as charged by the Sentinel, then what is left? And if the nation's intellignentsia is either ignorant or oblivious of it, then we are really in deep doo-doo. >>two, I think it's a stupid decision to send >>incompetent and supposedly corrupt judges out to >>anywhere in India, not just Assam. *** But it was not ANYWHERE to which these stained personalities were destined. They were to places like Assam, Bihar, Kashmir. If we cannot recognize its implications then we are being disingenuous. >>three, i don't know of any country in the world -- at >>least a democracy -- which enables the people of a >>state or province to elect/select a judge. *** We are all ignorant of many things. However this statement is a rather unexpected one that explains the indifference to the issues at hand. I am surprised that Hazarika is unfamiliar with the essential elements of American federal democratic republic, having been a reporter with the NY Times. In American democracy, the electorate in the states DO choose their judges. The state supreme court justices are nominated by the chief executive of the state, the governor, an elected position. And the nominated justices MUST be confirmed by both houses, the state congress and the state senate. State supreme court justices are not appointed by Washington DC or the US supreme court justices. No US Supreme court justice could dare contemplate sending a discredited justice to a less developed state as a punishment, much less after declaring it so. >>we have a constitution which, flawed as it may be, is >>one of the finest documents in the history of the >>world and has come to the rescue of people time and >>again -- and thrown up outstanding people to fight for >>public rights: H.R. Khanna (remember habeas corpus in >>the emergency or perhaps some of you are too young to >>remember this; we resisted the emergency and so did >>some courts); Seshan and Lyngdoh, Niloy Dutta, the >>National Human Rights Commissi! on! (JUstice Verma) and >>others to name a few. they've forced the government to >>change its views, position, acknowledge its mistakes >>and forced changes in earthquake relief, child labour >>etc. we could go on. *** None of that changes the gravity of the abomination charged by the Sentinel. The constitution maybe the best document in the world, but it isn't worth a paisa more than HOW it is used or HOW its sanctity is enforced. I cannot appreciate the prestige of a constitution that affords a high court judge CONVICTED of corruption to receive its punished by being sent to the high court in Assam or Bihar or Kashmir. It would not take a constitutional scholar to see the emptiness of the constitutions importance. >>but, always, i have felt that we of the ne think too >>often with our hearts and not our heads. the former >>is important and a combination of heart and head is >>the best. but let's not substitute the former for the >>latter; it is physically unhealthy to say the least. *** Cliches are not enough to explain away what is patently wrong, and what ought not to stand. >"but, always, i have felt that we of the ne think too >often with our hearts and not our heads. the former >is important and a combination of heart and head is >the best. but let's not substitute the former for the >latter; it is physically unhealthy to say the least." > > > >When the opposition to the appointment of judges came from the bar >association, that is a case of using the head. If there are street >demonstrations for this, then the head is not being used. People in Assam >must learn how to use the tools available in the framework of Indian >constitution. If some tools are missing it is the responsibility of the >citizens to bring it up so that there can be a discussion on it. All of >this makes sense only if one believes in the concept of Assam being a part >of India. Otherwise all of the above is hogwash. ** The bar association's opposition is one thing, but a system that even allows the highest echelons of the nation's judiciary to take as cynical and patently disdainful actions towards the people of a state, then the whole system is profoundly flawed, colonialistic and ought not to be accepted by the constituents of a supposedly federal democractic republic. But unfortunately we know all too well how federal or how democratic the Indian union is. cm ________________________________________________________________________________ At 12:13 PM -0800 12/7/02, D Deka wrote: >The essence is in this paragraph: > >"but, always, i have felt that we of the ne think too >often with our hearts and not our heads. the former >is important and a combination of heart and head is >the best. but let's not substitute the former for the >latter; it is physically unhealthy to say the least." > > > >When the opposition to the appointment of judges came from the bar >association, that is a case of using the head. If there are street >demonstrations for this, then the head is not being used. People in Assam >must learn how to use the tools available in the framework of Indian >constitution. If some tools are missing it is the responsibility of the >citizens to bring it up so that there can be a discussion on it. All of >this makes sense only if one believes in the concept of Assam being a part >of India. Otherwise all of the above is hogwash. > > > >Dilip > > > > Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > >What do you think Dilip? > >At 11:31 AM -0800 12/7/02, D Deka wrote: >>Jayanta, >> >>Do you agree with what Mr. Hazarika said? How about the others in the net? >> >>Dilip Deka >> >> jayanta payeng wrote: >> >> >> >> >> >> sanjoy hazarika wrote: >> >>Date: Thu, 5 Dec 2002 17:33:39 +0000 (GMT) >>From: sanjoy hazarika >>Subject: Re: ur discussion, from sanjoy hazarika >>To: jayanta payeng >> >>i have seen the correspondence on the judges. >> >>a few points: let's be logical in discussions, not >>hysterical like some Sentinel editorials (I remember >>one which even said that a few thousand armed >>intruders could sweep into Assam from Bangladesh >>without anyone being able to anything about it -- >>well, whoever wrote that piece doesn't know that when >>such a situation is apprehended and develops, the >>charge of the border goes to the army and not the bsf. >>and the army is capable to dealing with some armed >>intruders, at the least. >> >>two, I think it's a stupid decision to send >>incompetent and supposedly corrupt judges out to >>anywhere in India, not just Assam. >>three, i don't know of any country in the world -- at >>least a democracy -- which enables the people of a >>state or province to elect/select a judge. we pick >>the agp for political office and they make a mess. we >>pick the congres, and they make another mess. judges >>-- please stay away from that one. leave that to those >>empowered to do so under the constitution -- and >>remember they sent such judges after repeat after >>consulting the sitting chief justice of that high >>court!! >> >>we have a constitution which, flawed as it may be, is >>one of the finest documents in the history of the >>world and has come to the rescue of people time and >>again -- and thrown up outstanding people to fight for >>public rights: H.R. Khanna (remember habeas corpus in >>the emergency or perhaps some of you are too young to >>remember this; we resisted the emergency and so did >>some courts); Seshan and Lyngdoh, Niloy Dutta, the >>National Human Rights Commissi! on! (JUstice Verma) and >>others to name a few. they've forced the government to >>change its views, position, acknowledge its mistakes >>and forced changes in earthquake relief, child labour >>etc. we could go on. >> >>but, always, i have felt that we of the ne think too >>often with our hearts and not our heads. the former >>is important and a combination of heart and head is >>the best. but let's not substitute the former for the >>latter; it is physically unhealthy to say the least. >> >>sanjoy hazarika >> >> >> >>__________________________________________________ >>Do You Yahoo!? >>Everything you'll ever need on one web page >>from News and Sport to Email and Music Charts >>http://uk.my.yahoo.com >> >> >> >> >> >>Have a nice day ! >> >> >> >>Jayanta Payeng >> >> >> >> >> >> Do you Yahoo!? >>Yahoo! Mail >>Plus - Powerful. Affordable. >>Sign up now >> >> >> >>Do you Yahoo!? >> Yahoo! Mail >>Plus - Powerful. Affordable. >>Sign up now > > > > > >Do you Yahoo!? > <http://rd.yahoo.com/mail/mailsig/*http://mailplus.yahoo.com>Yahoo! Mail >Plus - Powerful. Affordable. ><http://rd.yahoo.com/mail/mailsig/*http://mailplus.yahoo.com>Sign up now
