C'da,

The question was how NRAs could get involved, given
what we understand and know about the functioning of
Govts at the Center and at the State.

>That is, in my view, is one of the major stumbling
>block of NRA participation remains.

IMHO, NRAs can do very little to affect any drastic
change in governance. So, they can only work with
Controllables, and within the ambit of local
governance.

Few of us will have the time and patience to go on a
crusade to make long-term commitments to affect
desirable changes in governance. So, we have to
concentrate only a few things that have a fighting
chance.

> I don't know whether you are in business or in
> employment ( can you imagine that-- having known you
>and Alpana for as long as we do, I still don't know
>that?)-- not that it is important for the discourse; 

Unfortunately (or fortunately), both of us just
run-of-the-mill 'onery' employees. Though, I too have
had my brushes with business, and rubbing shoulders
with some business folks in Houston, while I was in
the Chamber of Comm.

Yes, I do understand the red-tape that you go thru, it
probably still exists.

> >NRAs can set-up a small agri bank, that provides
> >seed/fertilizers. 
> Of course they can. But charity, Ram, is NOT an
> answer to these problems.

You misundertand, this is NOT charity. Agri-banks can
set up fertilizer or equipment soft loans to a group
of farmers (or individuals). The group as a whole
would be responsible for the loan, and in the end they
sould actually be able to own the equipment. These
need not be expensive tractors, but could be small
equipment or even cattle.

NRAs would have to select some affected areas to help.
And details could actually be worked out, IF NRAs are
willing. The Gaonlia banks were meant for this
purpose, but I am not sure how successful they have
been

This is just an idea, and naturally has to vetted
thru. It won't cost us an arm & a leg, but will be of
great help where needed.

Now, you might say, this is for the Govt. to do etc,
but IF NRAs were to wait for a perfect set-up, we will
never be doing anything at all. Actually, that could
be used as a good excuse for not doing something :-)
 
We all know the problems, but to make a dent, in some
small way, we would need to take these up as small
projects.

> But I do know WHY, the state puts up the road-blocks
> it does...

It well may be so. But that should not be a reason for
NRAs trying out something on their own.

As an example, if NRAs as a group were to open an
account with a commercial bank, they would have more
clout to ask the bank to help out to loan processing
and help. Many NRAs in other parts of India have done
just that. The huge bank accounts of some of the NRA
associations allow them to help the bank focus on
areas of interest such as opening health clinics in
rural areas. 

>Even the avowedly non-violent Indian independence
>movement had a tremendous amount of violence
>asociated with it.

True, BUT the leaders like Gandhi, Nehru, etc NEVER
advocated violence and in fact the main thrust of the
Independence movement was based on non-violence. That
is why it is still given as an example. The Salt-
Satyagraha easily comes to mind, where the British
soldiers were using violence and the movement leaders
were observing non-violence - THAT is why that
movement was a great one.

The ULFA on the other hand, publicly announce and
advocate violence. The main M.O. seems to be to get
their independence thru the vehicle of violence. C'da
there is just no comparison, and there is just no way
to justify it either.

I remember a quote from Gandhion on violence, it ran
something like this :

"If independence for India has to come thru violence,
then I don't any part of it..... "

What kind of independence would it be, where the
canons are based on violence?

>Similarly, can we make a serious argument, that since
>many young folks from Assam have left for Delhi,
>Bangalore, Hyderabad, Ahmedabad etc., they are no
>longer attached to their Assamese identity. That it 
>is a a myth? That they are really more connected to
>the pan_Indian identity that some of us attempt to
>promote?

This thing about identity has many facets. So,
Assamese living in other parts of India, obviously
first identify themselves as Assamese. They are very
much attached to Assam (even stronger links exist).

But those living outside of India, now deal with an
additional identity. They identify themselves as
Indian and then as Assamese or Bengali. And its great
-one can be an ardent Assamese and an ardent Indian
(and an ardent American) at the same time, don't you
think? :-)

--Ram






--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> Ram:
> 
> 
> Didn't mean to leave with the loop open. Was busy
> and Wasbir's 
> article came in the way :-).
> 
> You make some good points.
> 
> 
> 
> >The way I see it, there has been progress in Assam,
> >but the progress seems lopsided. The rate could
> have
> >been better, if it wern't for the other problems
> like
> >graft, bureaucracy etc. But I am more of an
> optimist.
> 
> 
> 
> I agree there has been progress,slow and
> insignificant as it might 
> be, but I would submit, it is in-spite of Assam
> governance and Indian 
> governance placed obstacles. I know it is a broad
> indictment, but I 
> can explain it, one at a time.
> Not that it is needed, anyone interested in
> understanding it, already know it.
> 
> That is, in my view, is one of the major stumbling
> block of NRA participation
> remains. And that was why my hypothesis.
> 
> Of course there are other reasons too. I won't
> dismiss the other 
> reasons off hand either.
> 
> 
> >Ah! you seem to have identified a perinial problem
> >about not being able to get loans for businesses
> >easily and that too at very high rates.
> 
> 
> I don't know whether you are in business or in
> employment ( can you 
> imagine that-- having known you and Alpana for as
> long as we do, I 
> still don't know that?)-- not that it is important
> for the discourse; 
> but getting started on a business is not as simple
> as many of our 
> wannabe-entrepreneurs make it out to be, even in a
> business friendly 
> environment as the USA. Otherwise we would not see
> most of these 
> highly skilled folks sitting on safe desk jobs in
> teaching or 
> mega-coporations. I know. I did business, heh-heh
> :-) in Kolkata, 
> before I left. And I can prove it too, with the
> grief I took with the 
> income tax folks. And to add insult to injury, the
> case officer was a 
> gentleman from Guwahati at the Kolkata IT Office,
> who did not release 
> the certificate of clearance until the closing hours
> of the Saturday, 
> the day before I was flying out. Luckily for me,
> another IT Officer 
> ,from Guwahati again, who comforted me with the
> inside info. that 
> this other fellow could not legally hold up my
> immigration plans. 
> Turns out, about a year later, that I overpaid my
> dues. But I did not 
> ever see the refund :-).
> 
> Maybe things have changed some. But I know, NOT a
> whole lot. Most of 
> my extended family members are second or third
> generation business 
> folks, but with spotty successes. The STATE and its
> bureaucracy are 
> the primary obstacles.
> 
> 
> >NRAs can set-up a small agri bank, that provides
> >seed/fertilizers.
> 
> Of course they can. But charity, Ram, is NOT an
> answer to these 
> problems. It is the STATE, which is responsible for
> making it easy 
> for people to take care of themselves, instead of
> providing the 
> obstacle course.
> 
> But I do know WHY, the state puts up the road-blocks
> it does: To 
> prevent those who already control things with their
> cartels from 
> establishing an even larger
> monopolies, while the institutions which are there
> to take care of 
> those issues remain dysfunctional. Unfortunately it
> ends up being 
> 'apwnaar naak kaati xotinir jatra-bhongo koraa'.
> 
> These are not issues that could be soft-pedalled as
> things that could 
> be worked around  by the novice, so that one can
> avoid rocking the 
> boat. To hold up 'working within the system' as a
> virtue, does not 
> hold any water at all. In fact it is exactly the
> opposite. It is 
> aiding and abetting , and thus prolonging, Assam's
> and India's 
> drifting in the doldrums.
> 
> 
> 
> >Well, in such a scenario, the Ulfa will likely be
> the
> >new leaders. Its difficult to predict what they
> will
> >or won't do (governing). But they are burdened by a
> >history of violence. How will such people govern?
> >Whats your take?
> 
> 
> 
> 
> I take a more sanguine view of this. The history of
> most new nations 
> have some violent history. Even the avowedly
> non-violent Indian 
> independence movement had a tremendous amount of
> violence associated 
> with it. Actually far more than
> some other not-so-non-violent ones.
> 
> Not that it is desirable, or something to hold up as
> 
> par-for-the-course. But the established
> 'authorities' rarely let go 
> of their positions of power without the threat or
> incidences of 
> violence.
> 
> My gut feel,( it is just that, because I don't know
> any of the main 
> players in the ULFA movement) is that they do
> network with 
> specialists, people of proven abilities. It is not
> like a small group 
> of guerilla fighters is what it is all about.  I
> have heard that they 
> seek and receive advice from some very able and
> successful people, in 
> many different fields, right there in Assam. Which
> leads me to think, 
> they would bring these people on board, should they
> ever be able to 
> persuade India to let them form a sovereign Assam
> state.
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> >This is purely a question of patriotism/hetitage.
> For
> >many, it helps identify themselveselves and their
> >heritage. I think this a more nobler thought than
> say
> >questions of whether or not an independent Assam
> will
> >succeed/fail or who the leaders will be etc.
> >
> >Yes, for many its just that - a very strong sense
> >being of Indian heritage.
> >
> >Logic defies such feelings. For example, take the
> >worst country in the world, and they will probably
> >tell you they are proud to be from that country.
> And
> >the situation in India is nowhere close to doomsday
> as
> >many would like to paint it as.
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> You make some very pertinent observations here.
> particularly about 
> "--Logic defies such feelings", a strong force that
> we tend to ignore 
> 
=== message truncated ===




                
__________________________________ 
Do you Yahoo!? 
Take Yahoo! Mail with you! Get it on your mobile phone. 
http://mobile.yahoo.com/maildemo 
_______________________________________________
Assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

Reply via email to