C'da

> It was not to question or devalue Gen. Singh's
> intents. But HOW on earth does the soldier on the
>beat or his officer differentiate between the "local
>population" and the "insurgents"? 


But more often than not, I am sure the army KNOWs when
it is the insurgents, specially when they are firing
at them. Common people in India do not have guns and
mortars, its either the army/police or the insurgents
who have them.

Also a 'humane treatment' can be advised when
interogating suspects. I am sure we don't want the
army to beat the c..p out of possible suspects, and
they turn out to be innocent bystanders.
I think, it does go a long way for the general to
atleast tell his soldiers what the general policy
guidelines are.

> How would YOU differentiate if you were in Gen.
> Singh's boots?

I am no general (just a generalist-:)). But in most
circumstances it might actually be easier than you
think. The times it may be hard is when insurgents
mingle with the local crowd and detonate a grenade or
something. 

> The Manorama case of Manipur is one of only
> thousands of such cases. The army has been given a
>free hand to dispense summary justice for half a
>century over the Nagas and for a quarter in Assam.

The insurgents on the other hand have been holding
these areas to ransom for the period. The army is a
reactionary force, C'da, if insurgents didn't go about
killing and rampaging, then we wouldn't see the army
deployed at all, would we?

But, nevertheless, maybe the army now sees that they
have been belligerent at times. I am not sure where
you get your stats (thousands of times), but assuming
its true, then surely the General is trying to put in
place a new policy, that should actually be good for
the local populace.

> How does that speak of Indian democracy Ram?

This has nothing to do with Indian democracy. The fact
that these various insurgent groups like to have their
own fiefdoms, and the country tries to quell down
these groups has really has no bearing on democracy.

Do you think the good ole USA would sit on the
sidelines if a rebel group were to ask for Texas
independence. Does Ruby Ridge ring a bell ? 
A democratic country has the right to protect itself
from subservive elements from within and without the
country.

What do you expect India to do? Just sit back and let
the insurgents go an a rampage? Wouldn't you blame
them then for being inactive? In fact, that is where
one should actually fault Delhi for - they just sat
back for a long while and let these simmering problems
become big ones, as the insurgents probably knew that
Delhi would take a long time to react, and that
emboldened them.

> I read recently that the Indian Army is now resigned
> to the unique character of Indian democracy, where
>it will continue to be required to play the role of
>the police and the courts, for civil law-enforcement

This is nothing new. At times, it may require that a
force that has little interaction with the public at
large perform certain functions outside the normal
scope. This would actually help the army have a better
understanding of civilian behavioral dynamics, and be
more attuned to the needs of civilians. The army is
also known to help in floods(even in the US) and other
local natural emergengies.

> negotiate with the insurgents, give a little and
> gain a little, and make peace.

Isn't that what the GOI was trying. But the ULFA
didn't want to go ahead because of some nuances and
splitting hairs to no end. But anyway, it looks like
the talks may be back on track again - hopefully.

--Ram



--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

> 
> Ram:
> 
> It was not to question or devalue Gen. Singh's
> intents. But HOW on 
> earth does the soldier on the beat or his officer
> differentiate 
> between the "local population" and the "insurgents"?
> 
> How would YOU differentiate if you were in Gen.
> Singh's boots?
> 
> Obviously the instructions mean little, considering
> the situation. If 
> the insurgents were to wear uniforms of an
> identifiable kind, it 
> might be different.
> 
> And if there was a way to differentiate, why has the
> army sought, and 
> will not let go of AFSPA? Even in the most
> benevolent of a 
> perspective, one cannot ignore the fact that the
> soldiers are only 
> human, scared of their own lives, while the enemy
> and the friends, 
> the natives, look all ALIKE.
> 
> 
> The Manorama case of Manipur is one of only
> thousands of such cases. 
> The army has been given a free hand to dispense
> summary justice for 
> half a century over the Nagas and for a quarter in
> Assam.
> 
> 
> How does that speak of Indian democracy Ram?
> 
> I read recently that the Indian Army is now resigned
> to the unique character
> of Indian democracy, where it will continue to be
> required to play 
> the role of the police and the courts, for civil
> law-enforcement and 
> summary justice, instead of being the protectors of
> the nation from 
> outside enemies. So they are making plans to train
> the armed forces 
> for its newly legitimized role.
> 
> What do you think of that Ram?
> 
> If I were to be in Gen. Singh's boots, heaven
> forbid, I would tell 
> the civil government to get off its fossilized duff
> and reform police 
> and justice systems , make them effective and
> dependable, and 
> negotiate with the insurgents, give a little and
> gain a little, and 
> make peace.
> 
> c-da
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> At 7:12 AM -0800 2/11/05, ram Sarangapani wrote:
> >C'da,
> >
> >The poor General JJ Singh. He is damned if he does
> and
> >damned if he doesn't.
> >
> >All he said was to "adopt a "humane approach"
> towards
> >local population" and deal "severely" with the
> >insurgents.
> >
> >And the reasons he may have adopted this maybe
> because
> >of the fallout of the Manorama case and other times
> >when the army may have gone overboard dealing with
> >innocent locals.
> >
> >Obviously, the army has to deal differently with
> >insurgents as opposed to the local population.
> >
> >If you were 'incharge', how would you deal with
> >insurgents?
> >
> >--Ram
> >
> >
> >
> >--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> >
> >>  Dear Editor:
> >>
> >>  I noticed the laudatory references to the new
> Army
> >>  Chief and hope for
> >>  his setting a more humane and progressive course
> for
> >>  the forces' ways.
> >>
> >>  In reference to the news item below, headlined
> "Deal
> >>  humanely with locals",
> >>  Gen. Singh's sets his noble course.
> >>
> >>  My only question, however, remains on the issue
> of
> >>  how an army
> >>  'jawan' or even an officer, from somewhere in
> North
> >>  India or South
> >>  India or even NE India, differentiates an
> >>  "insurgent" from a member
> >>  of the "local population"? It creates the
> impression
> >>  that the
> >>  insurgents in Nagaland or the entire NE, are
> animals
> >>  of a different
> >>  stripe from the "local population".
> >>
> >>  Is it really so?
> >>
> >>  If it is not, and I am certain General Singh is
> >>  eminently aware of
> >>  the condition; then one is left wondering if
> there
> >>  is much value to
> >>  his
> >>  declaration of humane intents. The
> >>  interchangeability of labels, between
> >>  the "local population" and the "insurgents",
> leave
> >>  ALL of them
> >>  legitimate targets for dealing with "severely",
> like
> >>  it has always
> >>  been. One cannot escape the fact here that it is
> an
> >>  attempt to peddle
> >>  old wine in a new bottle.
> >>
> >>  It is depressing to see the ever widening gap
> >>  between Indian leaders'
> >>  ( both political and military) long pronounced
> >>  declarations that
> >>  political problems require political solutions;
> and
> >>  their continued
> >>  actions. Playing with smoke and mirrors of
> benign
> >>  language goes only
> >>  so far. Too bad Indian democracy has not yet
> figured
> >>  out the
> >>  difference between an effective  civil law
> >>  enforcement apparatus and
> >  > a judiciary that could be depended upon to
> dispense
> >>  timely justice in
> >>  matters of internal conflicts, and the use of
> the
> >>  armed forces,
> >>  however humane, employed to dispense summary
> justice
> >>  on their fellow
> >>  citizens, every time.
> >>
> >>  Chandan Mahanta
> >>  A North Easterner
> >>
> >>  Writing from:
> >>
> >>  St. Louis, USA
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>
> 
=== message truncated ===



                
__________________________________ 
Do you Yahoo!? 
Meet the all-new My Yahoo! - Try it today! 
http://my.yahoo.com 
 

_______________________________________________
Assam mailing list
[email protected]
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Mailing list FAQ:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/assam/assam-faq.html
To unsubscribe or change options:
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/options/assam

Reply via email to