|
Ram,
No worries. Left - Right, we all walk in the centre and keep
time!!
AKN
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Tuesday, February 15, 2005 9:59
PM
Subject: Re: [Assam] Chomsky's detractors
- Hindu, Walia & Gajendran
C'da,
You are right. I am no leftie, in fact I
consider myself as being in the middle. So, AKN can stop worrying
-:).
I have read a number of articles by Chomsky, and he does make
us look at things in a different light. But whether I agree with him or
not, I would like him to be heard in the US media. I have very rarely heard
him being covered by any of the major media. One does like to have a
sense of balance, AKN, don't you think so?
Now, we don't want right to
be wrong, and the left to be right, do
we?
--Ram
--- Chan Mahanta <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
wrote:
> No Anjan. Ram is no leftie :-). It was Nalinkashya >
from Canada who > used to send them to us. > > > I
haven't read the article Ram posted-- it is long > and will have to
> wait. But even though he is not widely reported in > the mass
media, he > does influence those who think a tad bit more than >
the average Joe on > the street. In that he is not
inconsequential. > > c > > > >
> > > > > > > >
> > At 8:27 PM +0800 2/15/05, Anjan K. Nath wrote: >
>We used to have Ram Dhar (I think), an ardent > Chomsky fan, who
used > >to post articles and news on Chomsky from time to >
time. > >I wonder where Ram is now. Seems to have left
the > NET to another Ram. > >Hai Ram, > >Anjan >
> > >----- Original Message ----- > >From: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>ram
Sarangapani > >To: <mailto:[email protected]>Assamnet >
>Sent: Tuesday, February 15, 2005 12:55 PM > >Subject: [Assam]
Chomsky's detractors - Hindu, > Walia & Gajendran >
> > >I came across this pretty well-written article on >
why > >Chomsky has been literally ignored in the US, by >
the > >media and the intelectuals. > > > >Its
surprising, how a country like the US can > totally >
>marginalize someone like Chomsky. > > > >Would be
interested what netters think. > > > >-Ram >
> > >______________ > ><http://www.hinduonnet.com/thehindu/thscrip/print.pl?file=20050225000307600.htm&date=fl2204/&prd=fline>http://www.hinduonnet.com/thehindu/thscrip/print.pl?file=20050225000307600.htm&date=fl2204/&prd=fline& >
> > > > >REVIEW ARTICLE > > > >Culture
of resistance > > > >SHELLEY WALIA > > >
> > >K. GAJENDRAN > > > >Noam Chomsky. >
> > >THOUGH The New York Times has called Noam Chomsky >
>"arguably the most important intellectual alive" he > >holds a
marginalised position as a political critic > in > >the
academic world. Those opposed to him are of the > >opinion that he
should confine himself to > linguistics > >and not dabble with
a discipline he is not trained > in. > > > > >
>But if The New York Time considers him such an > >intellectual
giant why should he not be taken > >seriously as a political thinker?
Chomsky draws > >attention to the remark: "If you go back and
look > at > >the context of that remark, the sentence
was: > >`Arguably the most important intellectual alive, >
how > >can he write such nonsense about international >
affairs > >and foreign policy?'" His books are rarely >
published > >in the United States; Editors of The New York
Times > or > >The Washington Post are reluctant and afraid
to > answer > >calls about their alienation with Chomsky.
These > >papers along with "experts in legitimation" limit >
>themselves to information that goes only in favour > of >
>the elite power structures. > > > >On the other hand,
intellectuals such as Chomsky > >constantly "undermine this
legitimation and thereby > >the individuals and interests associated
with this > >particular position". These privileged educated >
>elites, including journalists, academics and public > >relations
officers, all "have a kind of an > >institutional task, that is to
create the system of > >beliefs which will ensure the effective
engineering > of > >consent". > > > >Chomsky
hits out at such a "secular priesthood", to > >use Isaiah Berlin's
phrase, that engages in this > kind > >of state adulation. He
goes on to explain: "This > means > >worship of the state
religion, which in the Western > >democracies incorporates the
doctrine of submission > to > >the masters of the system of
public subsidy, > >privatisation, and profit, called free
enterprise. > The > >people must be kept in ignorance, reduced
to > >jingoistic incantations for their own good." >
> > >Over the years, Chomsky's resistance to the U.S. >
and > >his sincere revelation of truths about its >
involvement > >in various countries have been much appreciated
by > >Edward Said, Howard Zinn, John Pilger and many more >
>eminent scholars around the world. On the other > hand >
>there are a few writers, rather offensive, who have >
>contributed to the Anti Chomsky Reader with the > marked >
>aim of disparaging all his work, may it be in the > area >
>of West Asia politics, Latin American violence or > his >
>main professional area of linguistics. Belonging to > >the Far
Right, they refuse to believe anything > Chomsky > >has to say.
They make Chomsky out to be "an > >intellectual crook". >
> > >The writers in this collection lack sufficient data >
to > >counter Chomsky's facts, which if "fabricated" or >
>"misquoted" would by now have come out in the open. > If >
>these allegations had some truth in them he would > have >
>been exposed long ago; various international bodies > as >
>well as the state governments whose role he > >interrogates would
not have taken "lies" about > their > >credentials lying
down. > > > >If Chomsky has equated the U.S. with the
Soviet > Union, > >or has lent full support to the anti-U.S.
sentiment > he > >has taken full pains to marshal minute
facts > carefully > >picked from the past 100 years of American
history, > >laying bare, to cite Edward Said, "a panorama of >
>futile violence, intellectual dishonesty, and > >political
immorality". > > > >Ronald Radosh and David Horowitz discuss
Chomsky's > >gloating reaction in this anthology of essays to >
the > >September 11, 2001, attack. Linguists Paul M. >
Postal > >and Robert E. Levine examine Chomsky's linguistics >
and > >find the same imperfections there that others see >
in > >his politics: "A deep contempt for the truth, >
descents > >into incoherence, and verbal abuse of those who >
>disagree with him." Levine and Postal, in an essay > >aptly
entitled "A Corrupted Linguistics", are > likewise > >critical
of Chomsky's overstated findings. In both > his > >linguistic
and political writings they find "a > >monumental disdain for
standards of enquiry, a > >relentless strain of self-promotion and a
penchant > for > >verbally abusing those who disagree with
him". When > >asked about the established results of his >
findings, > === message truncated
===
__________________________________ Do you Yahoo!?
Read only the mail you want - Yahoo! Mail SpamGuard. http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail
|