I'm from Jorhat and when I speak I never get an uvular effect, more 
so with front vowels in words like /xex/. ... - 
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/message/2368

Thought, the IIT Guwahati analysis is an account of the native 
Assamese.

Here are the IIT Guwahati links:
http://www.iitg.ernet.in/rcilts/Wave/word/assamese/X.wav
http://www.iitg.ernet.in/rcilts/Wave/word/assamese/STONE.wav
http://www.iitg.ernet.in/rcilts/Wave/word/assamese/xul.wav
http://www.iitg.ernet.in/rcilts/asamiya.htm

X.wav above is what is the reference phoneme of Assamese native 
speakers as per IIT Guwahati. But if you listen to STONE.wav you 
would realize a mistake, as X.wav does not have spectral match 
STONE.wav for what they called /x/.

... the /k/ of Kamrup/Nalbari ('velar voiceless plosive'to go by 
phoneticky descriptions)is much 'backer' than the one produced by 
people from my part of the state. - 
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/assamonline/message/2368

Kamrupi people are coward of scholarly Shakuntala :)
Their Kamrupi great grand used the old Devnagari script-set along 
with several foreign alphabets including digit 7 and 5 that look like 
Roman and symbol /nita/ looks like Greek /nita/ as well. But Kamrupi 
did not use some conjunct as we find in modern Bengali script set 
(Assamese uses the same Bengali-developed scripts – the Ratne
script 
I developed is a replica of the same). Kamrupi will be better 
represented if they just hold on to the Old Devnagari style of 
mapping -- surprisingly all phonemes exits spoken in different areas 
of undivided Kamrup further west to Coosh Behar, strong in northern 
areas of villages. --BUT Kamrupi people are coward of scholarly ...

The IPA authority did not do any analysis on Kamrupi either.

Lets talk on native Assamese and IIT Guwahati paper first in order to 
explain/understand why they claim voiceless/unvoiced. Please try 
validate conducting spectral analysis. The same PRAAT tool that 
Shakuntala posted will be good enough, i.e., http://www.praat.org/

Create your own phoneme as you speak and post the results, we want 
practical results not observation.

Would like to thank Priyankoo (www.geocities.com/priyankoos), Bezbora 
and Sanjib for writing to me in person.

The solution of the two assignments will follow.

Rabin









Reply via email to