I am of the opinion that the culprits ( from the agitators as well as locals) 
responsible for such a heinous crime should be brought to books and given 
punishment so that such incidence never happens in future.

This has undoubtedly shown the failure of the local administration.

BKPait
Manager: ISOM
7886


>>> Rajeev Bhattacharyya <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> 11/26/2007 1:37 PM >>>
I thought i should share  my views on this topic given that i am a senior 
journalist in guwahati working with Times Now and also because i am a resident 
of Beltola in Guwahati where this incident happened.

the administration was caught on the wrong foot completely which gave both 
sides enough opportunity to indulge in the mayhem.   but the police did succeed 
in breaking the procession ahead of Last Gate which is appreciable but the fact 
remains that their reaction was too slow.

lets be practical....the miscreants can't be punished......there's no 
record...none of the media houses including us were able to get hold of footage 
showing the adivasis induling in the agitation...but only the retaliation by 
locals and that too from a distance....miscreants cant be identified....i dont 
mean to support the locals but ive always advocated a practical approach to 
solving problems but departing from making shrill slogans like what some 
political parties always do.

now regarding the media....i wonder if you have seen the snap published by 
Telegraph on page 1 the next day...this is what i call responsible 
journalism....it shows a person preventing others from hitting an adivasi woman 
lying on the road...but have you seen what other dailies have published?  well, 
some amount of sensationalism can't be prevented but there's always a line to 
be drawn.

will you believe that a news channel showed a lady being paraded naked? ..... 
my question is ...why was it shown a day after the incidents and not on 
saturday?  what is the objective of the news channel?  does it want to inflame 
passions?  assam is a  multi ethnic state and an incident like this can have an 
adverse repurcussion in other parts.

kindly ponder over what i've said and let me know your opinion.

warm regards.

Rajeev Bhattacharyya

pmalakar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
The vandalism of the agitionists was condemnable, but, its retaliation was most 
barbaric and shameful.

For the entire thing the leadership of the agitionists, the civil 
administration and the police are responsible. The Government should take stern 
actions against the erring officials.

Again, the miscreants, who indulged in the violence should be punished 
immediately. It would not be difficult to identify them because it was all in 
camera.

The soothing thing is, at least for once, the media are behaving sensibly.

Paresh Malakar


This e-mail message is only to be used by intended recipients and all others
may kindly delete it and notify the sender. Unless expressly authorized by
HPCL, the views expressed and the message itself is that of the individual
sender and recipients are cautioned to check messages/attachments for any
viruses before use. Users acknowledge that messages may contain confidential,
 proprietary or privileged information and that HPCL neither assures nor
guarantees integrity or content of messages.


Reply via email to