These are issues of taste.

The text of a single mote may be 1024 characters in length.
Historically they were kept terse to save storage.  This rationale for
brevity is no more,  I therefore try to provide very full information
in error mnotes, including any contextual information that is likely
to be helpful.

Macro definitions are often written by programmers who are less
accomplished than the programmer who wrote the corresponding macro
definition; and it is, I think, his or her responsibility to diagnose
any errors, syntactic and semantic, that are accessible, even if the
result is longer than it otherwise would be.   Brevity may well be the
soul of wit, but in this context it is unhelpful.

Specifically here, it is my view that if duplication is an error just
what hs been duplicated must be made clear, unambiguously so.

Our notions of what constitutes 'eye candy' are thus very different.
We indeed disagree sharply, but that does not distress me and should
not distress you.

John Gilmore, Ashland, MA 01721 - USA

Reply via email to