The last time I needed to look at the reference data manual was recently when I 
had occasion to set up a translate table to replace all "non-printable" 
characters with periods in a COBOL application program (INSPECT ... CONVERTING) 
for some dump-formatted report output, so I used the character tables in the 
reference manual to pick out the right ones.  I used the online IBM PDF for 
that, though somewhere around here I do have paper copies of green and yellow 
and maybe even one salmon physical reference card (if only I could remember 
where I last left them . . .).

I could just as easily have used one of the Wikipedia EBCDIC pages for that 
information.

Still, my vote is yes for the reference summary to continue to be generated.

Peter

From: IBM Mainframe Assembler List <[email protected]> On Behalf 
Of Dan Greiner
Sent: Monday, October 20, 2025 2:47 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Do you still use the IBM z/Architecture Reference Summary (SA22-7871)?

We ancient fossils fondly remember the "IBM System/360 Reference Data" 
(X20-1703), better known as the green card ... a 12-panel folded document that 
summarized the instructions, mnemonics, operands, and hardware data structures 
of the original IBM S/360. The appearance of a green  card in a shirt pocket – 
likely behind a pocket protector full of pens – identified the bearer as a true 
believer ... a programmer not to be trifled with. Over the decades as the 
architecture grew from 151 instructions to well over 1,200 in the current 
z/Architecture models, the green card grew into a reference-summary booklet (of 
varying colors) that now exceeds 100 pages. 

In this century, IBM eschewed hard copies by (a) providing these documents in a 
PDF for free, and (b) charging outrageous prices prices for hard copy; then 
about 10 years ago, they dropped hard copy completely. For the PoO, this was 
understandable ... it now consumes over two reams of paper  and costs a bundle 
to ship. However, for the Reference Summary, this made the publication MUCH 
less useful. (I have actually printed a copy, trimmed it down to size, taken it 
to Kinko's for comb binding, and never looked at it again. )

Since all of the information in the Reference Summary can be found in the PoO – 
and it seems unlikely that IBM will come to their senses and make hard copy 
again – it seems ridiculous to bother producing it any more. I asked the 
current editor of the documents his opinion, and he agreed that it's unlikely 
that the Reference Summary is useful any more. 

This seemed like a great forum to solicit informed opinions. However I do 
hesitate, knowing that some will take this as an opportunity to vent their 
spleen about documentation in general.  Please don't. I simply wish to provide 
feedback to the Systems Architecture group as to whether this document is used 
in its current online-only format.
--

This message and any attachments are intended only for the use of the addressee 
and may contain information that is privileged and confidential. If the reader 
of the message is not the intended recipient or an authorized representative of 
the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination of this 
communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication 
in error, please notify us immediately by e-mail and delete the message and any 
attachments from your system.

Reply via email to