James M Snell wrote:

This feed does not validate.

    * line 2, column 0: Unexpected dir attribute on feed element [help]

          <a:feed xmlns:a="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom";

Because the dir attribute is defined by an I-D, Sam has agreed to change
the validator to return a warning instead of an error but this opens up
a more general question about the use and treatment of non-namespaced
extension attributes within Atom.

I don't understand how this can ever be a validation error. Atom doesn't disallow them, XML doesn't disallow them.

(the point made later about the RNC disallowing non-namespaced attributes is neither here not there)

cheers
Bill

Reply via email to