Sam Ruby wrote:

I am still confused.

Transforming an Atom feed into another format does not result in a valid Atom feed.


Right, but it's useful for the tranformation.


If I am conflating validity with media types, then so is the XML specification.


I don't understand that, could you explain?


If the validator does not look to the spec for guidance, where should it look?


If somebody can answer my questions, I would appreciate it..


I think the spec should cover Atom documents identified with the Atom media type. Other types are undefined.

Robert Sayre



Reply via email to