willyhoops;198878 Wrote: > anyone with the vast skills required to build a real sophisticated drm > that makes everyone happy would make a fortune.
You don't understand. DRM can not work in the way that you think it can, and it's not a matter of someone not having enough "skills" to have done it yet. The ENTIRE BASIS of DRM is to hide the key from the user. You are giving them the encrypted thing and the key to decode it, and hoping that they can't find the key because you have obfuscated it. Any sufficiently determined programmer can find it, no matter how hard you try to hide it. So the only thing that makes DRM "work" is to hide its mechanism by trade secret, or to make it illegal to "traffic" in a "circumvention device" which is already what the DMCA does. As a matter of fact, a russian programmer visiting the US was JAILED for revealing that Adobe had defrauded the customers of its eBook software. Adobe claimed that it contained sophisticated, secure encryption when in fact is was a trivial XOR function against a repeating string. So if that's already illegal under current law, how much more legal support do you suggest DRM needs? Should we behead the programmers? Given that DRM works by hiding the key from the user, what exactly makes you think that a "platform independent" DRM scheme could ever work? Any standard would be "cracked" instantly - indeed, if the spec is opened then there is NOTHING TO CRACK! It's not a matter of technical prowess on the DRM supplier's part to prevent that from happening. This is really basic stuff that has beaten to death a zillion times since the DMCA has been introduced. I won't even get into how ridiculous it is to expect that you can lock down the whole thing to the point that nobody can get their hands on unencrypted music any more. It's just absurd. -- seanadams ------------------------------------------------------------------------ seanadams's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=3 View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=34928 _______________________________________________ audiophiles mailing list [email protected] http://lists.slimdevices.com/lists/listinfo/audiophiles
