At 09:47 PM 1/06/2008, you wrote:
" Conclusion: Never change a good working system."

Hear hear Gerrit.

I'm surprised an issue of this consequence to pilots has been considered "in camera" and ended up in an official 'draft' without prior open dialogue.

Rules review is an inevitable on-going process and aspects of it will be log jammed by reiterative and unending public dialogue. But clearly some issues, critical safety issues in particular, deserve open debate at forums like the Pilots meeting at National Comp level. This appears to be such a matter.

Dion Weston

PO Box 5062 (34 Chisholm Street)

Greenwich, NSW 2065 Australia

Mb (0408) 859-267


On 30/05/2008, at 11:59 AM, Gerrit Kurstjens wrote:

I've only got a small dog in this hunt as our glide computers must handle rule changes and display appropriate information at the right times.

So here's a suggestion:

After the Nationals pilot's meeting, set up a list server like this one where the issues raised and the minutes of the meeting are published. Allow 4 weeks for comment. Then decide on a proposed rule taking the comments into account and publish the *proposed* rule. Allow a final comment period of a couple of weeks then enact the rule, modified if necessary. Restricting comment to current Nationals pilots is probably counterproductive as there will be those contemplating taking part in the future and others who may no longer be taking part but have flown under various different rules and you never know where a little wisdom is going to come from and it is smart to avoid making the mistakes of the past again.

Those familiar with the CASA rule making system may recognise this process albeit with a compressed timescale.

Mike
Borgelt Instruments - manufacturers of quality soaring instruments for over 25 years ABN: 75532924542
phone 0746 355784                       
fax   0746 358796                               
cellphones  0428 355784
            0429 355784
email:   [EMAIL PROTECTED]
website: www.borgeltinstruments.com
P.O.Box 7474 Toowoomba M.C. 4352
Queensland Australia

_______________________________________________
Aus-soaring mailing list
[email protected]
To check or change subscription details, visit:
http://lists.internode.on.net/mailman/listinfo/aus-soaring

Reply via email to