Gary Schnabl wrote:
ghrt wrote:
Gary Schnabl wrote:
But you brought up the point of the "majority." What skill level does the mainstream or typical user have at this point in a computerized society? Do they need to use screen captures to learn how open a file today versus ten years ago? I doubt learning that is needed anymore. [Just stating the menu command to use to open a file should suffice.]

GSG isn't some kind of 'learning how to use the computer' guide, but let's be sincere, if you have to open a book in order to learn how to use an office suite you are not used to computers, so the book should start from the basic things. But there is an excess of images, I agree. And - those usefull- maybe we just crop them and flow the text around them?

Should the user guides other than GS receive the same treatment pertaining to screen captures for basic tasks?

Depending on their level. If they'll offer non-basic level, no, because I don't expect an absolute beginner in need of page styles and cross-references. If we decide that's best to begin from 0, yes, because if we talk for these guys we must be understand by them, not by some kids which learn much easier basic tasks, related to computer or not.


I don't want to write a guide for complete idiots. If we talk about Save menu we may embed a screenshot of it, with some explanations floating over the picture. Because it will be much easier to understand. If we talk about some complicated feature which requires planning, like Base or macros, most screenshots are (almost) useless.

I also look at these guides as intented to be read on computer screen, so for me all this issue with page count is not important. The problem is how descriptive GSG must be, and my answer is to cover all major and daily features for ordinary office work.

Reply via email to