I would prefer to keep it out of framework for the simple reason that it is not directly associated with commissioning or decommissiong a component. It can standalone inside another excalibur component.
FYI I also think that poolable threadsafe and friends should not be in framework. On Fri, 9 Aug 2002 01:17, Leif Mortenson wrote: > Today the instrument build got complicated to make a circular > depencency between instrument > pool and altrmi work correctly. Now the instrument build contains two > seperate builds. One to > build the core classes, and a second to build the instrument manager and > client. This was exactly > the reason why I had wanted to have the projects split up originally. > > The core instrument classes are very simple and have absolutely no > dependency on anything > else. Where as the manager and client are much more complicated > involving lots of dependencies. > > The core instrument classes by design are used by lots of other > packages. Where as the manager > is only used by containers. The client is a seperate application.. It > doesn't really matter where it > lives. > > What would you think of moving the core instrument classes over to > framework? That would > make it easier to integrate it more fully into various avalon components > without having to worry > about dependency issues. Another option would be to move the > instrument manager and client > classes back into a seperate instrument-manager package. > > Thoughts? > > As things are now, the instrument build file has to get called > twice. It works now, but I can us > getting into a situation again soon where it won't. > > Cheers, > Leif > > Peter Royal wrote: > >On Wednesday 15 May 2002 04:05 pm, Peter Royal wrote: > >>I've thouroughly beat upon my components to handle connection pooling + > >>general ECM-friendly integration of altrmi and I'm ready to commit them. > >> > >>Catch is, this would introduce a dependency upon framework to altrmi, > >> which is something we probably don't want to do. So i'm not sure where > >> this stuff should go... > > > >These components have been committed. Altrmi already had a framework dep. > >-pete -- Cheers, Peter Donald *-----------------------------------------------------* * "Faced with the choice between changing one's mind, * * and proving that there is no need to do so - almost * * everyone gets busy on the proof." * * - John Kenneth Galbraith * *-----------------------------------------------------* -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> For additional commands, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
