Hi Eran, I agree about the custom MEPs and using reflection. What I would like to clarify is whether the raw XML message receiver not only uses reflection, but always expect a certain method signature in the reflected classes, is that so? Suppose I have some hashtable with mappings of service operation => actual method signature. I.e my operation is sayHello but my actual implementation would need to invoke SAY_HELLO(...) . Then , as far as i understood from the talk above, the Raw XML Message receiver would fail since the reflection-based search in findOperation() would not succeed. Thanks
Regards, Angel On 1/14/07, comain <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Yes，it works just as perfect as you said. That is really cool. However, if we are using POJO based web services with RPC MR (as the quickstart example), it works with a lot of reflections indeed. As a developer, since I konw little about WSDL, the way I prefer is to write POJOs with my own business logic first, then deploy it as a ws with a default service.xml. In this case(maybe the common case), does Axis2 has no way but using reflections all around? If this is a problem, we may work around in the following ways: A possible work around is, the developer first write its own skeleton(dummy), then using java2wsdl to generate wsdl for him, then using code gen with ADB to generate effective sevice skeleton, after which developer now adding his business logic. Or change the code gen module not using WSDL information, but Service Classes directly(Since wsdl can generate from service class). In this case, developer need not to provide wsdl before write his service, but write the service with his own will, then using the ADB code gen to generate necessay auxiliary classes directly. If this is not a problem, can you kindly point out how does axis2 elegantly handle this case? Great thanks, Eran. ________________________________ comain 2007-01-14 ________________________________ 发件人： Eran Chinthaka 发送时间： 2007-01-14 13:17:51 收件人： [email protected] 抄送： 主题： Re: Custom Message Receiver use cases -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Comain Chen wrote: > Hi, Eran > > I am quite interested in your 2nd reason. > > However, it seems that you can only avoid using java reflection during > operation routing. Before it starts to invoke the specific operation, it > has to deserialize the XML document into corresponding operation > parameter objetcs, which will use Java reflection(If you use any binding > frameworks, such as ADB, JAXB, etc.), and is more performance critical. Well, we do not do that, at least in ADB. The ADB data objects, that are code gen'ed directly works on StAX. What you have, when you are just about to de-serialize, is a StAX reader, from the input stream. ADB is designed to work with StAX. IIRC, we do not need reflection in this case. > Of course, if you decide to write your own data binding with RawXMLMR, > you can still avoid this with a lot of painful work. I totally agree with you. But most people do not want to get in to the hazel of writing yet another data binding framework. We know, from experience, how difficult it was :). And 95% of the people, in my guess, like to work with java objects, than with raw XML. - -- Chinthaka -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.3 (GNU/Linux) Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org iD8DBQFFqbzYjON2uBzUhh8RAiptAKCVz+7gviwJzMHbiqF9KobMaO/gzgCfWbIE KD9WF5amy+NyeqF/MyibAKQ= =81vD -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
