Hi,

Thanks to Steve, Michael, Paul, Stephen, and Andrew for their replies to my previous posting.

I've still not been able to get in contact members of the Innovation Culture team at the BBC in order to invite them to consider participating in an FP7 Internet and Communication Technology/Future and Emerging Technology proposal. But, perhaps someone there reads this list, so I'll knock on this log-drum a bit more. Besides, perhaps there are others who would be interested.

The basic idea:
To develop an online decision-support tool that supports dynamic, collaborative, open, devolved, multi-lingual argumentation using a controlled language which parses the input, then transforms it into a formalised, implemented language of argumentation that enables automatic calculation of justified claims. Output is generated in natural language or as an argument graph.

Simply put, users would enter their comments in a structured format (natural language rather than semantic web markup), the automated part of the system would parse the input, provide a semantic representation, link the comment to previous comments in a structured way, then calculate results of the current standing of the "debate". We have a concept of how to do this in a reasonable fashion; we have an excellent team of collaborators.

The BBC's role would be to provide data, user requirements, and a test context for this system. The comment blogs give us data to analyse how such debates are currently used; the results of our analysis would contribute to the construction of the tool. The BBC is interesting to us because it supports comment debates, has a public mandate, and functions across languages. The tool would productively use and contribute to the BBCs comment content.

Turning to some of the specific suggestions.

Paul suggested:
Have Your Say has an RSS feed of comments
http://newsforums.bbc.co.uk/nol/rss/rssmessages.jspa?forumID=5700
You can get more than the standard 20 or so messages it throws out by
adding &numItems=500 to the URL.

This works nicely and I see how to get more from similar blogs I also now see that other blog sites (Guardian) also allow one to download all comments with respect to a particular posting.

The drawback is that I have to go from blog to blog manually. I would prefer some central, indexed repository (if one exists) of blogs plus comments.

Stephen commented on this point:
...someone involved in that section of the bbc site might be able to point you to a raw feed of all comments within a forum. I'm sure Ian can find out if it is possible to open up some form of official comment feeds to backstage.

However, I've not heard more about this (it is only Monday though...)

I don't see how to make use of Stephen's comment:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/blogs/ <-- posting/accessing directly is restricted to invite only, i suspect it only works when added to a blog by SSI.

Andrew wrote about another source of comments:
a comments feed for a most interesting recent post on BBCi Labs, is
http://www.bbc.co.uk/dna/blog131/rss/acs?dnauid=movabletype131_40565

What I took away from this is that where there are blogs with comments, I should
1.  Look to see if there is a list of all blog comments available
2. Look at the page source to see what sort of information on rss is available, as that might allow me to link to where the comments are stored?

One additional point, I didn't know this previously, but there are apparently blog specific search tools. If I knew more about the URL structure of the blogs with comments at the BBC, I could use the search tools to search within a specified domain. That could be helpful.

In any case, many thanks for these suggestions.

Cheers,
Adam

----------------
Dr. Adam Wyner
Department of Computer Science
King's College London

-
Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group.  To unsubscribe, please 
visit http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/archives/2005/01/mailing_list.html.  
Unofficial list archive: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/

Reply via email to