Hi all,


We were out of town for the last couple of days & hence could not reply with
our part of the analysis (Or I prefer to call it as Paralysis). My apologies
for making you people wait for my reply.



Few friends here speculated that the following could be the possible reasons




1. Fuel

2. Adulteration

3. Carbon formation etc....



Each one of you was right with your points of view but still the tale was
incomplete.



We began our investigations with the usual inspection of parts, detailed
history enquiring the customer etc.... but found nothing unusual. During
these investigations there were a few pulsar owners, who joined us as
spectators (not the silent type) & went on to criticize the quality of the
product, cheap quality etc…. Hence I thought it would be a nice idea to
share the learning we had from this case.



Any failure needs to be looked in the reverse course of action which as
rightly pointed out is sheer speculation. Speculated info is then tested
with reality & possibilities etc then causes are ruled out one after the
other.



Sample testing of fuel & oil happens right at the bottom of the
investigations to check for any external causes. We tried to take out a
sample of the fuel from the fuel tank for testing, is when we realize that
the fuel was adulterated. It is every thing other than a "proper combustible
fuel".



The aroma of this fuel sent us into short time dizziness & was on the verge
of making us Nauseate. Upon dipping the finger into the fuel, the fuel was
not evaporating as it should/ would, instead stayed on & left a layer
similar to plastic lamination. In fact the erect lab grade plastic burette
which was used for sample collection was bent when the sample was poured
into it during the course of investigations.



Upon closely re-examining the cylinder head, intake ports, carb manifolds
etc... We found a gummy layer formation.



These are the tell tale pictures.



Gumming at the intake port



http://picasaweb.google.com/v.v.shyam/TechnicalPhotos/photo#5210529171554200898



http://picasaweb.google.com/v.v.shyam/TechnicalPhotos/photo#5210529141213195026



Sample of the gum sticking on finger



http://picasaweb.google.com/v.v.shyam/TechnicalPhotos/photo#5210529455206624930



As mentioned the gum was taking over 2 secs to release the fingers out with
full force.



All these are simply pointing to the reason......  "Adulterated fuel used "
which is not covered under warranty.



NOW: What could have happened?



The gummy substance formation has happened all over the intake port & valve
seat area. Either the Valve stem or valve face has got struck when the bike
was stopped overnight & hence the engine could not crank (battery down
feeling) as reported by the customer.



When the engine was being forced to start by the push start method the
forces exerted have separated the valve stem & the head (Which is evident
from the fact that the valve stem is still struck inside the valve guide).
Due to the starting pressures/ forces, the valve head has fallen on the
piston crown & has resisted the movement of the piston to the top. Since the
engine was being cranked forcibly, the piston crown made way with a hole.
The subsequent pounding on the piston crown by the valve head has caused
major damages to the cylinder head, piston & partially to the Crankshaft
connecting rod (the extent of damage around the connecting rod is yet to be
ascertained).



At a later time one of the loose pieces of metal (could either be the inlet
valve head or the shattered piece of Piston crown) has got struck in between
the exhaust valve & its seat causing the exhaust valve head to be sheared
off too.



When the customer was confronted with these facts, the boy from who's
apparently a student (living away from parents) confessed to the fact that
he was in the habit of using petrol bought from small shops in order to meet
his spending needs & never filled fuel as a planned activity.



Armed with these facts, the BAL officials ruled out the failure due to
Manufacturing quality or process being wrong. The Warranty was hence denied.




The customer now has to pay up for cutting corners & the cheap alternate
fuel is now proving that it's the costlier option.



In the internal Bajaj Circles I am known as the "Devils Advocate" & I must
admit that I had no case to fight here & had to bow down to the decision.
The Cost of repair is going to about Rs.9000/- Plus & the entire bill is to
be footed by the Owner & no one else.



This case has been presented to you as learning, learning "what not to do"



Hope you have your share of learning … though it might not classify itself
as "learning for a life time".

-- 
Bye & have a Safe Ride

Venkat Shyam,BV
Auto Service
(M) +91 94480 40349
Log on to : www.auto-service.blogspot.com
www.talking-banyan-tree.blogspot.com
email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]


------------------------------------

__The Bajaj Pulsar User Group__
      www.bajajpulsar.org
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/bajajpulsar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/bajajpulsar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
    mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [EMAIL PROTECTED]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Reply via email to