When I sent my previous email, I was hoping that you wouldn't go off
on a tangent with the points you would put forth to explain your
argument. Sadly, it looks like you have. At this point, I dont want to
argue with you anymore, so this will be my last reply on this topic.
And trust me when I say this, no hard feelings, and I still respect
you :).

Continued inline.

On 7/18/08, Navendu Singh <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> > Yes, but this bike didnt fall. Which is why I'm surprised that the fuel 
> > leaked
> >
> Since you agree that when bike falls, fuel will leak thru fuel cap, in
> all bikes. Right? So, its a design flaw in "all" bikes?
> Your falwless pulsar don't leak fuel when fallen, with fuel in tank?

Right, but this bike didnt fall, it was merely parked. Right? And
there is no need to transform this discussion into a Pulsar vs. other
bikes argument.


> You fill the bike to brim. To an extent that fuel will spill out. Then
> lock the tank and put the bike on side stand. Do it and share your
> experience.

Done it. Once, even filled 21 ltrs in the tank (LOL, i know the fuel
station guy cheated me. Needless to say, I've never been to that place
again). I dont remember fuel spilling out of the tank.


> > Never seen this happen on my Pulsar. Could this be design flaws on
> > Fieros and Bullets? (I'm asking a serious question, please dont
> > consider this flame bait - considering the amount of fuel in the air
> > :) ).
> >
> As I said above, let me repeat it.
> "You fill the bike to brim. To an extent that fuel will spill out.
> Then lock the tank and put the bike on side stand. Do it and share
> your experience."
>
> Yes, Fiero and Bullets are flawed bikes. Sadly, only few lucky people
> get to ride the flawless Pulsar.


Nav, I'm not an idiot. When I said that I did not see this happening
on the pulsar, I did mean on a pulsar with a FULL tank of fuel. See,
this where you went off on a tangent. I was trying to have a serious
discussion here and you made it a bike A vs bike B fight.

> > > - Also once on the bikes (Fiero and Bullet), while I was riding the
> > > bike, after a fill to brim, fuel started to come out. Reason was, when
> > > I filled the bike with fuel, there was some air in the tank. When
> > > riding in sun, due to heat, the air probably expanded and hence the
> > > fuel started to come out. No, I was not riding on bumpy surface, it
> > > was butter smooth section onf NH4.
> >
> > Again, never had this happen. I've had vapor lock once or twice on my
> > pulsar, but NEVER fuel leakage!
> >
> Have you "EVER" filled the bike to brim and did what I wrote?
> Unlike many "speculations" those were my "personal" experiences.

I have ALWAYS filled my bike to the brim. And I've ridden on butter
smooth highways as well. But what happened to you hasnt happened to me
so far (knock on wood).


> > This is scary though, if you consider
> > how many nutjobs just throw out their cigarette butts without stubbing
> > it out. Imagine if you ride over with, with fuel leaking out of your
> > bike. Scary stuff!!
> >
> If the experiences I shared about fuel coming out of tank, you call
> them "fuel leaking out of tank and falling on road". I guess you have
> never tried filling your bike to brim. Please get some first hand
> "experience".


Well I'm assuming the fuel came out and fell on the road. Possible,
right, depending on how much fuel spilt? And no thanks, I do not want
such scary first hand experiences. :)


> > > Now why I said that about the person?
> > > - Fuel coming out of tank, can't be missed seeing by nakes eye or
> > > smell by a functional nose. In this case the person missed both of
> > > them. If he can miss seeing it, such person in all probablity miss
> > > seeing people on road as well.
> >
> > Even people with good eyesight dont see somethings. How can you
> > compare not seeing a little trickling petrol to not seeing a person??
> > Was as much fuel as the volume of a human being flowing out of the
> > tank?? (this is a bigger design flaw that I first assumed!!).
> >
> Spill some fuel on tank and throw a buring match stick on it. Do it
> and then we shall continue.
> and all those who with good eyesight can't see people on road, they
> also fall in the same category as this person.

Wait. Are you saying the bike was on fire *before* the guy sat on it
and lit his cigarette? I know you did not mean that, but that's what
your logic is implying.

> > Sense of smell could be blunted due to lots of reasons. It could have
> > been windy, the guy could have had a cold, the smell of the cigarette
> > fumes could have masked the smell of the fuel. All this is conjecture.
> > The point is, when I buy a bike, I expect it to keep all the fuel I
> > fill in it.
> >
> You fill the bike to brim. To an extent that fuel will spill out. Then
> lock the tank and put the bike on side stand. Do it and share your
> experience.

Done it countless times before. nothing happened. just the way i like
it. I prefer the fuel to stay in the bike, and it did.


> > > - He lit a cigrate and was going to ride the bike. Means, he "might"
> > > not be wearing a helmet. Also while riding he would be many times,
> > > taking off one hand off bike (in traffic, I'm making this assumption).
> > >
> > > Now such person, in my view, are danger on road for other people.
> > > Thats why that statement.
> >
> > Still doesnt give you the right to say that he should have been blown
> > up. He's someone's son, could be someone's husband, someone's father.
> > He's only human, and so are we.
> >
> Those are also someone's someone who continue smoking in the gas
> station while waiting to get fuel (in two wheeler/four).
> Those are also someone's someone who continue use mobile phone in the
> gas station while waiting to get fuel (in two wheeler/four).
> Those are also someone's someone who ride/drive rashly in a dangerous
> manner on road.
> Now, I won't be too happy to be at the receiving end by the ignorance
> of such people. Hence that statement. If you are ok with it. Fine. I'm
> not.

Hoping that these kinds of people die is not a good solution Nav :).
Cos when they do, they will end up taking the sane ones out too.

--Nikhil

Reply via email to