On 05/15/2018 06:37:11 PM Tue, Peter Bloomfield wrote:
Hi Jack:

On 05/15/2018 04:06:40 PM Tue, Jack wrote:
Final issue, unrelated to POP3 or IMAP - this is something I've actually noticed for some 
time, but this mailing list seems to be the only one where I see this - Albrecht's 
previous response was TO: me, and CC: the list.  When I hit "G" to reply to the 
group, the reply windows comes up, but no address in either To: or CC:.  If I Reply All, 
it comes up To: Albrecht, and CC: the list, which is not wrong, but I have a personal 
preference to To: the list, and CC: the individual (which I often omit, especially if I 
know the person is subscribed to the list.).

As I recall, a cursory glance at the code didn't show a quick fix for that, but 
it definitely needs a fix! I'll look again…

So, here's the problem: if you hit 'Reply to group', Balsa tries to follow RFC 
2369[0], which describes how to handle 'mailing list command specification 
header fields', and, in particular, Balsa looks for a 'List-Post:' header. If 
the message you're replying to is the one from a conforming list, it finds that 
header and sets up the 'To:' field correctly. If you received a copy addressed 
to you directly, it doesn't have that header, and Balsa just gives up. A better 
reaction might be to pop up a dialog pointing out that the message doesn't 
appear to have been sent from a group, and suggesting 'Reply all' as an 
alternative.

What do you think?

Peter

[0] https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2369

Attachment: pgpnkUpfa1y22.pgp
Description: PGP signature

_______________________________________________
balsa-list mailing list
[email protected]
https://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/balsa-list

Reply via email to