>1. Goto "Extras/Duplicate Detector" in SBS web interface and start
>detection. You need to hit the "Refresh" link to see the current
>progress.
>
Running this now - will confirm how long it takes to complete against a library 
of 35871 tracks when its finished.

I note though that SBS reports I have 35852 songs, but Duplicate Detector says 
it is checking 35871 songs.  Could this be because it is picking up non-track 
records (eg. playlist names, urls to other resources, etc)?

>2. The default is to detect using the first 10000 audio bytes.
>
Not sure that it is going to be safe to take a sub-set of audio bytes (or at 
least without looking at other audio attributes too).  There could be different 
versions of songs that are edited, eg. the first part of the song is identical, 
but one version is a bit longer.  Perhaps the checksum also needs to include 
audio length, or take n bytes at the start AND n bytes at the end for the 
checksum calculation.

I can think of one example, where I have an album in two formats - the original 
where songs are distinct tracks, and an enhanced version where songs are 
cross-faded.

What about support for cue sheets?  i.e. a single audio file that is chopped up 
into songs via a cue sheet - each song references the same audio file, but with 
a different sub-set of the data.  Does the duplicate checker take account of 
this; treating each track as if it were a separate file chopped into segments?

So far, it has detected 113 checksum duplicates (all incorrect duplicates) out 
of 6856 songs (Duplicates: 0).

I looked at the results, and there are groups that I assume it believes are 
duplicates, such as:

64b80a25505a34d0c723dce617ced261-00d02343 M:\Music\Phil's Music\Blues\Canned 
Heat\Uncanned\01 - On The Road Again (Alternate Take).mp3
64b80a25505a34d0c723dce617ced261-0079bc14 M:\Music\Phil's Music\Blues\Canned 
Heat\Uncanned\02 - Nine Below Zero.mp3
[...in this case, all 45 songs on the album are listed...]
64b80a25505a34d0c723dce617ced261-001930fa M:\Music\Phil's Music\Blues\Canned 
Heat\Uncanned\45 - Huh.mp3

The first part up to the "-" is always the same, the second part of the number 
is different.  What does this mean?

Phil
_______________________________________________
beta mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/beta

Reply via email to