On Jun 27, 2013, at 18:02, Fischlin Andreas wrote:
> Apologies. I resend this hoping it will be more readable this time.
> Unfortunately this looks good on my side when I send it. So I do initially
> not know what goes wrong.
>
> On 27/06/2013, at 17:28 , Christiaan Hofman wrote:
>
>
> On Jun 27, 2013, at 16:33, Fischlin Andreas wrote:
>
>
>
> On 27/06/2013, at 13:08 , Christiaan Hofman wrote:
>
>
> On Jun 27, 2013, at 12:50, Fischlin Andreas wrote:
>
> Dear Christiaan,
>
> Ok. I understand now finally, sic. I was able to create from existing
> bookmarks the needed new bookmarks, which indeed do now the job.
>
> I guess then the problem is (once more) with the lack of an editor for the
> server settings or perhaps all settings of an existing search bookmark.
>
> My conclusions: I can do what I needed to do, but there remains an issue. I
> find this edit cycle again - I remember now, having stumbled previously over
> this BD design issue - not particularly user friendly, at least
> idiosyncratic, since not logical. Having reflected all what you said, then
> I'd say it is a general issue of BD that bookmarks can only be edited by
> using an existing bookmark (via choosing its menu), then editing that
> external group, then saving the edited group as a bookmark, and then
> discarding the original bookmark and replacing it by the newly edited/saved
> one.
>
> IMHO I find it hard to get ones head around this. If there would be a sheet
> to edit an existing search bookmark or perhaps any server settings, I guess I
> would never have had these difficulties to figure out how to actually
> accomplish a simple task such as setting preferences for a particular search
> group. Perhaps something you could consider. It may be very clear to you as a
> chief programmer of the GUI what steps need to be done to accomplish this
> task, but there is the danger with all this knowledge to forget about those
> like me, who do not share the same intimate knowledge with the internals of
> the software.
>
> In all software design I prefer to distinguish clearly between the user and
> the implementer's model and strive always to keep the user model as simple as
> possible and as user-friendly as possible. As a user of BD I know that there
> are some objects like "Search groups", "Data base server settings", "Search
> criteria", and then "Search bookmarks" with some relationships among them.
> For instance the latter consisting of the other elements, some of which are
> mandatory ("Data base server settings"), some optional (search criteria).
>
> So why not having another menu command to edit existing "Search bookmarks"
> which behaves similarly to the "New Search Group..." menu command, but which
> operates on an existing instantiation? Alternatively the menu command "Edit
> Search Bookmarks..." could of course also do that, if its dialog would be
> extended by being able to Ctrl-click a line and/or having an additional tool
> in the top toolbar that triggers the "Get Info for Group..." sheet. Then no
> new menu command would be needed.
>
> If any of these features would exist in BD, then I guess, all our discussions
> would never have taken place.
>
> Please consider. Otherwise thanks once more for all what you do.
>
> Regards,
> Andreas
>
>
> The problem is that the model is complex. The server information is complex,
> and therefore the UI for it is complex. and then there are the various things
> that can be edited, that make it complex. Adding more interfaces does not
> necessarily make things simpler, it complicates things even further. Your
> first suggestion is certainly a no-op, it confuses more rather than less (you
> could then edit 3 things rather than 2 in the same place: a group instance, a
> default server, or a bookmark) I also doubt that the discussion would have
> been avoided by adding new UI in a different place. Why would it?
>
> I seem to have a slightly different view, since I guess for the reasons I
> already gave. But I understand that this is complex and I am also for keeping
> it as simple as possible.
>
>
> In general, a bookmark is simply a static template. Always. When you choose
> it, you create an instance. I know of no app where changing that instance
> would change the static template, that makes no sense. For instance, when you
> choose a bookmark in a browser, and then change the address for the page, why
> would you expect the bookmark to change?
>
> Good example, yes I do exactly not expect it to change. However, let's not
> confound oranges with apples. I draw another conclusion from this. When I
> have an editor for bookmarks, I expect it to be able to edit the address of a
> bookmark when for instance the provider did change the web site. E.g. when I
> wish to keep a bookmark menu for BD's home page and the address of the latter
> changes, then I find it cumbersome having to first visit the new home page by
> choosing that bookmark menu (which does in this case no longer work) merely
> to preserve some of the previous settings of that bookmark, then having to
> save the new URL once successfully visited the new home page as a new
> bookmark, and then having to delete the old bookmark after having moved the
> new bookmark to the same command location where the old bookmark menu was.
> When I have an editor for bookmarks, as offered by all browsers AFAIK, then I
> expect to be able to edit the address of that bookmark directly, e.g. by
> adding creden
tials (our case) or editing the URL string otherwise. However, with the
current BD GUI this is not possible and that's what I believe is so difficult
to understand from the user's point of view.
>
>
> This is a request for a new feature. That is really a separate subject from
> what we're discussing, not directly related to the password/username but
> general editing of searches.
>
> Agreed.
>
>
> Moreover, I am not talking about more interfaces. I was thinking of using the
> same routine (edit sheet) for editing an existing instantiation as is used
> for editing a new instantiation. In my programmer's mind this simply means
> another argument for the same algorithm/routine/method, where properties are
> not empty (or predefined), but the last set ones for the instantiation being
> the argument.
>
> You can edit an existing group. However, that starts with the group as it is.
> It makes no sense to start from whatever you did last. Or if with
> "instantiations" you mean bookmarks (it's not what I would think of), then it
> is in fact new UI, even if it reuses old ones. But it's a separate, and
> different, question than what we're really talking about.
>
> yes, see above.
>
>
>
> Then I believe you have misunderstood me. I do not expect a static template
> to be changeable, of course not. That's exactly one of the reasons why I find
> the current solution so confusing, with having to start from an instantiation
> when one wishes to edit some properties of an entire class. Not only a long
> detour, but also a confusing one.
>
>
> The thing is that there really isn't something as a class. That's what you
> seem to misunderstand. There are just various presets. And you can edit or
> add new presets. This is because it's pretty versatile.
>
> In a user model there are objects, almost always, regardless whether you are
> conscious of that fact or not. And I believe that's not what you are
> referring to. But let's stop this discussion, since it goes way beyond the
> issue where we started and I agree that your solution offers much more
> flexibility than the one with the hidden preferences and it seems to work
> well according to my first tests. It only is quite "hidden" and probably
> anyway quite out of reach for many users.
>
> Therefore most of all, many thanks for your contribution (and to Colin) for
> making Web Of Science searching with BibDesk again possible. Thanks!!!!!!!
> :-)))))))
>
>
> Again, I believe, only arguments that speak for aforementioned editing
> feature that can modify the properties of an existing bookmark.
>
> But I am not hang up on this. I simply believe this needs improvement if
> possible, since current implementation is not sufficiently user model
> oriented.
>
> Regards,
> Andreas
>
> Maybe. But asking for an extra bookmark edit feature is a separate issue.
>
> Agreed
>
> Cheers,
> Andreas
>
>
> Christiaan
>
>
> Christiaan
>
>
> On 27/06/2013, at 11:26 , Christiaan Hofman wrote:
>
>
> On Jun 27, 2013, at 10:19, Fischlin Andreas wrote:
>
> Dear Christiaan,
>
> snip ...
>
> I found the possibility to enter for External Group "Web of Science SCI" via
> Ctrl-Click "Get Info for Group..." a sheet where I could enter UserID and
> password. Is this what you mean?
>
>
> Yes.
>
> Ok. Good. I understand now the way how you have implemented that. This is of
> course also quite a good solution, if it only would work (see below).
>
>
> However, this seems to be a most cumbersome method, since it seems I have to
> reenter all the time the UserID and the password upon each reuse of another
> ISI WOS Search (I have committed the changes using 'Set'), since the display
> of the two field's contents changes (I can't test this, unless I go home
> where I have no IP# authentication interference). Is this really what you
> intend to ask from users?
>
>
> You should only have to set it once. You can set the changes for the default
> group type, or create a separate default group type with the password. It
> doesn't change when you've saved the changes, it certainly doesn't for me. So
> you must have done something wrong if it changes for you.
>
>
> What could be the reason for the fact that it does not work? How can I set it
> globally and once and for all? Let me ask you once more whether what I do is
> really the technique intended. This is what I see as the only possibility to
> enter the credentials:
>
> 1) I choose BD menu command "Searches -> Web of Science SCI"
> 2) I Ctrl-Click on the resulting external group "Web of Science SCI" near the
> top left pane
> 3) I choose from pop-up menu "Get Info for Group..."
> 4) I click on arrow (top right corner) to cause the sheet for server settings
> to come down
> 5) I click onto button "Add"
> 6) I click onto button "Edit"
> 7) I dismiss the instructional dialog re using button "Set" by clicking
> button "OK"
> 8) I enter Username and Password
> 9) I commit the editing by clicking button "Set"
> 10) I dismiss the sheet by clicking button "OK"
> 11) I can finally enter a search criteria and cause a search to take place
>
> Up to here all fine, although I wonder how editing of a specific group should
> affect all groups of that kind.
>
> It doesn't. It changes the item in the default servers popup.
>
>
> 12) I repeat step 1)
> 13) I enter another search criteria
>
> Search fails due to authentication failure and indeed,
>
> 14) repeating steps 2) and 3) shows that no UserID nor Password is set for
> that second external group "Web of Science SCI" empty, only the first group
> for which I have gone through all these steps 3) to 10) can I successfully
> authenticate.
>
> You did not change the item in the search bookmarks menu. You should save
> that separately. The bookmarks are an already fully set up group. You could
> have also saved a setup group with password on the search bookmarks, rather
> than the default server popup. If you had done "New Search Group" and then
> chosen the item from the popup you would get the username and password.
>
>
> This is all unacceptably cumbersome.
>
> It's in principle a one-time setup. So I don't agree. You have to pass the
> information somehow.
>
> So I ask again, is this really the intended behavior?
>
> Yes.
>
> If that should be the case then I opt clearly to go back to Colin's solution
> with hidden preferences.
>
> Hidden prefs are bad. There's nothing in the app to tell the user it even
> exists.
>
> Security is no issue here, since you also store the password not in the
> keychain.
>
> If this is not the intended behavior as I hope is actually the case, then
> there is a bug in the implementation.
>
> No, a misunderstanding on your side. You did not understand that the 3
> buttons in the sheet refer to the default servers, i.e. the ones in the
> popup, as the label indicates. And bookmarks are specific instances of search
> groups.
>
> I guess it has to do with the fact that the editing can only be done (at
> least AFAIK) for a specific instantiation of the external group "Web of
> Science SCI" instead of the class of these searches. Only then I presume all
> instantiations could inherit the needed credentials.
>
> Please clarify.
>
> Thanks for your help and cooperation.
>
> Regards,
> Andreas
>
> It can be done for specific instants of search groups, *or* for default
> (preset) servers. But not for all instances of a generic type (there is no
> such information.)
>
> Christiaan
>
I've added editing capability to the search bookmarks. Double click or add the
new toolbar item.
Christiaan
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by Windows:
Build for Windows Store.
http://p.sf.net/sfu/windows-dev2dev
_______________________________________________
Bibdesk-develop mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bibdesk-develop