Hi Roman! On Wed, Aug 8, 2012 at 11:56 AM, Roman Shaposhnik <r...@apache.org> wrote:
> Hi Jos! > > On Mon, Aug 6, 2012 at 10:54 PM, Jos Backus <j...@catnook.com> wrote: > > I'm aware of that. We'd like to use MRv1 instead of YARN because we are > not > > ready/willing to switch at this point. The code is still there, just the > > mapred script UI was removed. Right now I'm using the hadoop command to > > start the jobtracker and tasktracker but it seems ugly and someone may > come > > in and break that interface, too, as it's advertised as deprecated. > > To the best of my knowledge that code in the trunk/branch-2 hasn't been > maintained for quite some time. It seems to compile, but I can't make it > work even with a patched version of wrapper scripts. Is your experience > with that code different? Can you provide more details on what exact > branch you're using and how exactly you're using TT/JT from there? > Well, I am using the CDH4 RPMs, being under the impression that the changes from the open source version are minimal. Are you saying that basically MRv1 is deprecated/unsupported at this point as far as the Apache folks are concerned? In that case, I should take the issue up with Cloudera if/once we have a support contract :) > > Please also note, that MRv1 as delivered by CDH4 distribution is completely > different from the code that exists in trunk/branch-2. > That doesn't bother me as it doesn't affect what I am working on :) I care about someone breaking this interface for no reason. I could understand it if MRv1 was no longer supported by Apache or Cloudera, but that appears to not be that case from what I can tell. So in my mind it's just a bug. > > So far the HDFS bits seem to work fine under daemontools-encore; I have > > been using it for several months now without problems. > > Great! Any chance you can share your code? > > I already did, I sent you an email on May 11th :) Right now I'm trying to get the scripts to work properly with CDH4, which is why I ran into this problem. Then I checked the Apache repo and saw that it was broken there, too, hence my email. At any rate, once I have the scripts in working order I will send an update. Thanks, Jos > Thanks, > Roman. > -- Jos Backus jos at catnook.com
