"Nonessential Projects Such as Sidewalks," etc.

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Ronald Dawson [SMTP:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]
> Sent: Thursday, March 15, 2001 5:41 AM
> To:   [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Subject:      [carfree_cities] Sound Familiar? 
> 
> From http://www.bluedogpress.com/news/opinion/?article=2001030801 Dawson
> 
> Auto-totalitarians
> 
> By Michael Lewyn
> 
> In most of America, the car reigns supreme. Commerce Department surveys
> show
> that less than 30 percent of Americans claim to have "satisfactory" public
> transit and that only 5.3 percent of Americans take a bus or train to
> work.
> Government stacks the deck in favor of driving by building highways and
> roads to virtually everywhere while providing public transportation to
> only
> a few cities and inner suburbs.
> 
> Nevertheless, some Americans bathe themselves in paranoia over the
> imagined
> superpowers of a vast anti-auto conspiracy. Writes Heritage Foundation
> pundit Steven Hayward: "Combining old-fashioned reformist idealism with
> the
> anti-auto animus, we will be...forced to be (car) free." And although the
> federal government spent $30.1 billion last year on highways (five times
> as
> much on public transit) then-Boston Globe columnist Jeff Jacoby complained
> a
> few years ago: "The car-haters aren't fooling around, and they're not
> going
> to give up until Big Brother takes the T-bird away."
> 
> And what evidence is there of this Vast Anti-Auto Conspiracy? The fact
> that
> a few people wish to give Americans transportation choices other than
> driving. In the San Francisco Chornicle, columnist Debra Saunders attacked
> Oakland Mayor Jerry Brown for "his anti-auto plan to put a rail system on
> the Bay Bridge". Jacoby writes: "Don't underestimate the intensity of the
> zealots' antipathy towards private cars. "We need bicycles and we need
> buses' demands environmental crusader Bill McKibben." So evidently, our
> fearless conspiracy fighters believe that if you support making it easier
> for anyone to ride a bus, or even a bicycle, you are an anti-auto
> "zealot."
> What the rest of us call choice, they call tyranny.
> 
> To be fair, reasonable people can disagree about the cost-effectiveness of
> some cities' expensive rail projects. But the blunderbuss of anti-transit
> ideologues swings against any alternative to driving, even the humble bus.
> For example, Jacoby writes: "We have far more mass transit than we need,
> but
> not nearly enough highway lanes. It is time to start spending the money
> where it's needed, and to make drivers, not straphangers, our top
> transportation priority." In Jacoby's own Boston, only 43 percent of
> entry-level jobs regionwide are within one-half mile of a bus stop - but
> Jacoby's statement that "We have far more mass transit than we need"
> suggests that he believes that 43 percent is too many, and that most jobs
> should be accessible only by car. In other words, he wants government to
> force us to drive by providing roads everywhere and transit nowhere. Even
> walking is politically incorrect in some quarters: although Atlanta has
> four
> interstate highways and a higher-than-average pedestrian fatality rate, a
> recent Atlanta Journal editorial was headlined: "Transportation Plan
> Should
> Push Highway Projects Rather Than Nonessential Projects Such as
> Sidewalks."
> 
> Despite their pseudo-libertarian rhetoric about people being forced out of
> their cars, pundits like Jacoby are basically auto-totalitarians: that is,
> they wish to create an absolute dictatorship of the automobile, a society
> where government, by providing roads everywhere and transit nowhere, makes
> it impossible to live without a car. The 94 percent of welfare recipients
> who can't afford cars, the 24 million Americans too disabled to drive, and
> the even larger number of children and teenagers too young to drive aren't
> even mentioned in any of the articles I quoted; the anti-anti-auto
> crusaders
> prefer to disregard their inconvenient existence.
> 
> The vision of the auto-totalitarians has come to life in America's smaller
> cities: for example, in Macon, Georgia (a city of over 100,000 people), 16
> percent of city households lack cars. Yet city buses only operate till
> 6:45
> in the evenings on weekdays, and not at all on Sundays, so people without
> cars can't reach the many entry-level jobs that require night and weekend
> work, or take a bus to church on Sunday. Rather than helping Macon's poor,
> the governor of Georgia recently proposed that the state spend over a
> billion dollars on one highway connecting two suburbs of Atlanta, enough
> to
> increase the number of city buses in Macon from 36 buses to 18,000.
> 
> What makes some Americans so angry at anyone who wishes to help
> nondrivers?
> Perhaps the auto-totalitarians feel secretly guilty over driving, and to
> assuage their guilt they seek to make it impossible for anyone to do
> otherwise. It could even be argued that they wish to isolate
> African-Americans (who are less likely than whites to own cars) in the
> inner
> cities by depriving them of transportation. But a more generous (and
> perhaps
> more plausible) explanation is simple selfishness: some drivers are happy
> to
> see government money spent on roads that help them, but don't want
> government to help nondrivers who disproportionately tend to be young,
> poor,
> old or disabled. So behind the loony theories about an all-powerful
> anti-car
> mafia, there may lie the reality of an overgrown child's voice chanting:
> "Me
> first!"
> 
> 
> 
> 
> ©2001 Blue Dog Press | Published March 12, 2001
> 
> 

Reply via email to