I attended the meeting last night. I found some interesting parallels
between this and some of the issues we face on land:

The basic question was 'sharing' a public facility. Everyone
agrees we all have a right to 'share' this public facility, but
disagree as to what sharing really means. For the motor-boat
crowd, this means that everyone can be on the lakes at the
same time. Paddlers counter that this effectively gives entire
control of the lake to the motor boats, who intimidate other users
of the lake with their size and speed. In addition, many
other people who do not own boats, but live near the lakes,
are also affected by the noise.  Many speakers noted that
boats are getting bigger and noisier every year.  And of course, motor
boats have a greater negative environmental impact on the
area.

The motor-boaters defended their 'right' to use the lakes with
arguments that are almost identical to those we hear for
the motorized land vehicles. They pay more taxes (gas taxes,
boat taxes, etc.) and hence they actually pay for the boat
landings, etc. We shouldn't restrict the activities of the
entire group because of a few 'nuts' - we just need more
education and enforcement, not more rules.  Also, we live
in urban enviroment, which is fast and noise, so thats part
of the deal.

Comments:
To adequately enforce the current rules would require
at least a 10-fold increase in the number of Sheriff's
deputies patrolling the lake. Will gas taxes cover that?
Cheers to the representative from the SAYSA neighborhood
for the eloquent appeal to make our cities livable.

Several speakers (both for and against expanding the no-wake rules)
compared non-motorized boats with bicycles. One person against
made the argument that bikes shouldn't ride in the street, they
are safer on bike paths, and the current 200 foot no-wake zone
is the equivalent of the bike path for paddlers. In other words,
you have a nice area to play in, why would you want to play where
its dangerous?


Finally, all arguments come down to land use issues. One of the
arguments for restricting no-wake zones is that motor boats
contribute to the overall decay of the lakes. The counter argument
is that the real problem is over development, and several motor-boaters
argued for increased regulation of development. Personally, I agree
with this point whole-heartedly. Excuse me, though, if I stop to
question their sincerity, since several of them openly called for
support of Dave 'never met a developer I didn't like' Wiganowsky
in the upcoming County Executive race.


> LAKES AND WATERSHED COMMISSION SEEKS PUBLIC INPUT ON DANE COUNTY
>SLOW-NO-WAKE BOATING REGULATIONS
> The Dane County Lakes and Watershed Commission has scheduled three public
>hearings on the county boating regulations (Chapter 72 of the Dane County
>Code of Ordinances).
>
>
>  Public Hearing #2: Wednesday, March 14, 2001 at 7 p.m.
> Courtroom 2E, City-County Building
> 210 Martin Luther King, Jr. Blvd., Madison, WI

--  -- -- -- -- -- --
Darin Burleigh        |><|\/|/\|-o
[EMAIL PROTECTED]   |<>|/\|\/|-o



Reply via email to