I think your proposal is simply to use BIP32 for all derivations and the observation that you can work with derived keys with the corresponding suffixes of the path. I believe that this is a good idea.
But I don't think that simply writing a standard will help. It's just one step. If all your wallets support incompatible formats, we should work on fixing this because that's the root of the issue. Otherwise you end up converting keys back and forth manually (as Chris pointed out), and this can't be the goal. But then you need to reach out to wallet devs explicitly and get them involved in creating the standard. Otherwise they won't use it. That's a hard process, and it's even harder to make sure that the resulting proposal isn't way too complex because everyone brings their special case to the table. Tim On Sun, 2020-03-22 at 11:58 +0000, Ethan Kosakovsky via bitcoin-dev wrote: > I have completely revised the wording of this proposal I hope to be > clearer in explaining the motivation and methodology. > > https://gist.github.com/ethankosakovsky/268c52f018b94bea29a6e809381c05d6 > > Ethan > > ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Original Message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ > On Friday, March 20, 2020 4:44 PM, Ethan Kosakovsky via bitcoin-dev < > email@example.com> wrote: > > > I would like to present a proposal for discussion and peer review. > > It aims to solve the problem of "too many seeds and too many > > backups" due to the many reasons stipulated in the proposal text. > > > > https://gist.githubusercontent.com/ethankosakovsky/f7d148f588d14e0bb4f70bb6afc509d0/raw/6da51e837b0e1f1b2b21f3d4cbc2c5a87969ffd5/bip-entropy-from-bip32.mediawiki > > > > <pre> > > BIP: > > Title: Deterministic Entropy From BIP32 Keychains > > Author: Ethan Kosakovsky ethankosakov...@protonmail.com > > Comments-Summary: No comments yet. > > Comments-URI: > > Status: Proposed > > Type: Standards Track > > Created: 2020-03-20 > > License: BSD-2-Clause > > OPL > > </pre> > > > > ==Abstract== > > > > This proposal provides a way to derive entropy from a HD keychain > > path in order to deterministically derive the initial entropy used > > to create keychain mnemonics and seeds. > > > > ==Motivation== > > > > BIP32 uses some initial entropy as a seed to deterministically > > derive a BIP32 root for hierarchical deterministic keychains. BIP39 > > introduced a method of encoding initial entropy into a mnemonic > > phrase which is used as input to a one way hash function in order > > to deterministically derive a BIP32 seed. The motivation behind > > mnemonic phrases was to make it easier for humans to backup and > > store offline. There are also other variations of this theme. > > > > The initial motivation of BIP32 was to make handling of large > > numbers of private keys easier to manage and backup, since you only > > need one BIP32 seed to cover all possible keys in the keychain. In > > practice however, due to various wallet implementations and > > security models, the average user may be faced with the need to > > handle an ever growing number of seeds/mnemonics. This is due to > > incompatible wallet standards, hardware wallets (HWW), seed formats > > and standards, as well as, the need to used a mix of hot and cold > > wallets depending on the application and environment. > > > > Examples would span wallets on mobile phones, online servers > > running protocols like Join Market or Lightning, and the difference > > between Electrum and BIP39 mnemonic seed formats. The reference > > implementation of Bitcoin Core uses BIP32, while other > > cryptocurrencies like Monero use different mnemonic encoding > > schemes. > > > > We must also consider the different variety of physical backups > > including paper, metal and other physical storage devices, as well > > as the potentially splitting backups across different geographical > > locations. This complexity may result in less care being taken with > > subsequently generated seeds for new wallets need to be stored and > > it ultimately results in less security. In reality, the idea of > > having "one seed for all" has proven to be more difficult in > > practice than originally thought. > > > > Since all these derivation schemes are deterministic based on some > > initial entropy, this proposal aims to solve the above problems by > > detailing a way to deterministically derive the initial entropy > > used for new root keychains using a single BIP32 style "master root > > key". This will allow one root key or mnemonic to derive any > > variety of different root keychains in whatever format is required > > (like BIP32 and BIP39 etc). > > > > ==Specification== > > > > Input starts with a BIP32 seed. Derivation scheme uses the format > > `m/83696968'/type'/index'` where `type` is the final seed type, and > > `index` in the key index of the hardened child private key. > > > > type > > > > bits > > > > output > > > > 0 > > > > 128 > > > > 12 word BIP39 mnemonic > > > > 1 > > > > 256 > > > > 24 word BIP39 mnemonic > > > > 2 > > > > 128 > > > > 12 word Electrum mnemonic > > > > 3 > > > > 256 > > > > 24 word Electrum mnemonic > > > > 4 > > > > 256 > > > > WIF for Bitcoin Core > > > > 5 > > > > 256 > > > > 25 word Monero mnemonic > > > > Entropy is calculated from the HMAC-SHA512(key=k, msg='bip-entropy- > > from-bip32') of the derived 32 byte private key (k). Entropy is > > taken from the result according to the number of bits required. > > This entropy can then be used as input to derive a mnemonic, wallet > > etc according to the`type` specified. > > > > ==Compatibility== > > > > In order to maintain the widest compatibility, the input to this > > function is a BIP32 seed, which may or may not have been derived > > from a BIP39 like mnemonic scheme. This maintains the original > > motivation that one backup can store any and all child derivation > > schemes depending on the user's preference or hardware signing > > devices. For example, devices that store the HD seed as a BIP39 > > mnemonic, Electrum seed, or BIP32 root key would all be able to > > implement this standard. > > > > ==Discussion== > > > > This proposal could be split into multiple discrete BIPs in the > > same way that BIP32 described the derivation mechanics, BIP39 the > > input encoding with mnemonics, and the derivation paths like BIP44, > > BIP49 and BIP84. This has been avoided to reduce complexity. The > > resulting private key processed with HMAC-SHA512 and truncated as > > necessary. HMAC-SHA512 was chosen because it may have better > > compatibility in embedded devices as it's already required in > > devices supporting BIP32. > > > > ==Test Vectors== > > > > ===Test case 1=== > > > > MASTER BIP39 SEED INPUT: angle fabric town envelope music diet bind > > employ giant era attitude exit final oval one finger decorate pair > > useless super method float toddler dance > > MASTER BIP32 ROOT KEY: > > xprv9s21ZrQH143K2xNoceSiUtx8Wb8Fcrk9FUfzD3MLT4eFx5NbBuof9Mwrf7CCbfG > > JNehNRHvrXnWvy9FtWVaeNggsSKT57GNk7jpk1PRzZDp > > PATH: m/83696968'/0'/0' > > BITS REQUIRED: 128 > > > > DERIVED CHILD > > WIF=L3cefeCHyo8jczVjckMxaiPBaPUunc3D8CsjRxYbYp3FhasGpsV3 > > DERIVED CHILD > > k=bed343b04ba0216d9eeebff0366b61c4179d90d44b61c716ef6d568836ba4d23 > > CHILD ENTROPY=6458698fae3578b48a64124ea3514e12 > > CONVERT ENTROPY TO > > WIF=KwDiBf89QgGbjEhKnhXJuH7T2Vv72UKQA8KRkmNwVFS2znAS5xb9 > > CHILD BIP39 MNEMONIC=gold select glue fragile fiscal fog civil > > liquid exchange box fatal caught > > CHILD BIP39 > > SEED=2a2720e5590d4ec3140e51ba1b0b0a5183222c1668977c8a57572b0ea55d23 > > 8cd8e899b3b1870e48894ca837e41e5d0db07554715efb21556fdde27f9f7ba153 > > CHILD BIP32 ROOT > > KEY=xprv9s21ZrQH143K2ZH5qacptquLGvcYpHSNeyFVCU8Ur4u9kocajbBgcaCbHkG > > bwDsBR661H29F54j5mz14kwXbY9PZKdNRdjgRcGfshBK9XXb > > > > ===Test case 2=== > > > > MASTER BIP39 SEED INPUT: angle fabric town envelope music diet bind > > employ giant era attitude exit final oval one finger decorate pair > > useless super method float toddler dance > > MASTER BIP32 ROOT KEY: > > xprv9s21ZrQH143K2xNoceSiUtx8Wb8Fcrk9FUfzD3MLT4eFx5NbBuof9Mwrf7CCbfG > > JNehNRHvrXnWvy9FtWVaeNggsSKT57GNk7jpk1PRzZDp > > PATH: m/83696968'/1'/0' > > BITS REQUIRED: 256 > > > > DERIVED CHILD > > WIF=L1zCbtnDWUN4vJA3De4sxmJnoRim57CQUuBb4KBoRNs2EMEq2Brg > > DERIVED CHILD > > k=8e3ca6054a6303f4a6a1bcbda6134c9802f4f0a0d76b0ee6b69b06b1e80b2192 > > CHILD > > ENTROPY=ec4e2f7e2c3fca9a34fa29747bf8ba0ab7f05136f37e134e2457e9e5363 > > 9670b > > CONVERT ENTROPY TO > > WIF=L594JSCygt2wBaB9mCpXjiLkkxkEojpBdNXG8UrrdLd2LvPBRMUs > > CHILD BIP39 MNEMONIC=unable imitate test flash witness escape > > stadium early inner thank company betray lecture chuckle swift hurt > > battle illness bicycle stable fat bronze order high > > CHILD BIP39 > > SEED=73509b0e847ee66bddeb098a55063d73e8c6dd5f1c1db6969c668bb54c19bd > > e6eae8acc29a81118d1d9719fa1bc620fee7edd7c15a17bcaf70b0fdfc0c0c3803 > > CHILD BIP32 ROOT > > KEY=xprv9s21ZrQH143K4PfLyyjYLVmKbnUTNFK6Y7jPKWfRZB3iSw1Gy9qowEzkYHf > > etVabfmjHEEPrcTJbh7chae33Sm9uAjuXzhSL6Li8dcwM9Bm > > > > ===Test case 3=== > > > > MASTER BIP39 SEED INPUT: angle fabric town envelope music diet bind > > employ giant era attitude exit final oval one finger decorate pair > > useless super method float toddler dance > > MASTER BIP32 ROOT KEY: > > xprv9s21ZrQH143K2xNoceSiUtx8Wb8Fcrk9FUfzD3MLT4eFx5NbBuof9Mwrf7CCbfG > > JNehNRHvrXnWvy9FtWVaeNggsSKT57GNk7jpk1PRzZDp > > PATH: m/83696968'/4'/0' > > BITS REQUIRED: 256 > > > > DERIVED CHILD > > WIF=KwdD5PYnCU3xQDfFJ6XBf6UDaLrTUxrKmBpdjRuuavWyqAQtpaA2 > > DERIVED CHILD > > k=0c169ce2c17bea08512a7519769e365242a1562bd63c4c903daef516000efbf2 > > CHILD > > ENTROPY=25573247f8a76799f7abc086b9286b5a7ccb03cb8d3550f48ac1e71d908 > > 32974 > > CONVERT ENTROPY TO > > WIF=KxUJ8VzMk7uWDEcwYjLRzRMGE6sSpwCfQxkE9GEwAvXhFSDNba9G > > CHILD BIP39 MNEMONIC=census ridge music vanish island smooth team > > job mammal sing bracket reject smile limit comfort pluck extend > > picture race soda suit dose place obtain > > CHILD BIP39 > > SEED=4e5c82be6455ecf0884d9475435e29a9afb9acf70b07296d7e5039c866e4d5 > > 4647706918b9d14909dfbd7071a4b7aee8a4ad0ac2bf48f0a09a8899dd28564418 > > CHILD BIP32 ROOT > > KEY=xprv9s21ZrQH143K2kekJsK9V6t4ZKwHkY1Q3umxuaAhdZKGxCMpHiddLdYUQBo > > ynszpwnk5upoC788LiT5MZ5q1vUABXG7AMyZK5UjD9iyL7Am > > > > ==References== > > > > BIP32, BIP39 > > > > ==Copyright== > > > > This BIP is dual-licensed under the Open Publication License and > > BSD 2-clause license. > > > > bitcoin-dev mailing list > > firstname.lastname@example.org > > https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-dev > > _______________________________________________ > bitcoin-dev mailing list > email@example.com > https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-dev _______________________________________________ bitcoin-dev mailing list firstname.lastname@example.org https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-dev