Hi AJ, On 2024-12-10 (Tue) at 06:13:50 +1000, Anthony Towns wrote: > Personally, I find it hard to take any of this remotely seriously at this > point; the most recent example is reardencode's claim to have created > scripts for lightning-symmetry using either LNHANCE or CCV. This was > done via a tweet [1] and a gist [2], without any real exploration of > what the full transaction flow would look like. Did it have any chance of > working? Well, no, because it had an invented "3DROP" opcode instead of > "DROP 2DROP" or similar, just as if it were ChatGPT hallucinating what > a wallet script might look like. That would have failed as soon as it > had been run through any of the script test environments out there, > let alone through any actual node software, so it's clear that nobody > involved had done anything of the sort, even locally. If the proponents > aren't taking their proposals seriously, why on earth should anyone else? > > [1] https://x.com/reardencode/status/1864749512113483993 > [2] > https://gist.github.com/reardencode/ae982ede45af12fe1ff7248fd6f1958c#file-ctv-csfs-vault-txt
You've made two strange errors in your commentary here. First, my example scripts for Lightning Symmetry all use opcodes that do not exist in the script testing environments so I cannot run my scripts through those environments. The point of the exercise is to demonstrate how the potential opcodes can perform an example protocol and roughly how the cost compares. The fact that I misglanced the opcode list during drafting is completely irrelevant to the exercise. Second, I am not a "proponent" of VAULT or CCV. I'm merely demonstrating various ways that they can be used, as a service to those who are discussing various options for upgrading bitcoin (as I strongly implied in my post on X - I only wrote the script you found an error in because of others' answers on Floppy's table). In other words, it's hard to take your commentary seriously when you don't bother to understand either the purpose and the context of what you are commenting on. Hope this clarifies. All the best, --Brandon -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Bitcoin Development Mailing List" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/bitcoindev/Z1dW77h3rhr5oivP%40console.
